Is There Any Light At The End Of The Tunnel For Reform In English Football? (pt 1)
Are we all a bit guilty of ‘Hitting the Snooze Button‘, for Football’s Nightmares to Continue?
2021, the middle of a pandemic and the English (and European) football world was shook again by a football bombshell and in many ways yet ANOTHER scandal, as the super rich clubs, their business savvy owners along with their investment bank and hedge fund backers arguably look for a breakaway and all new ‘gravy train’ with the ESL (European Super League).
In one way it could be seen as a welcome alarm bell for English football; galvanising the media, politicians, players, other clubs (left out of the apparent ‘carve up’) and most importantly the fans; to object to such a breakaway ……. as ‘greed’ once again invades the landscape of the so-called ‘beautiful game’.
Are We ALL Guilty of ‘Hitting the Snooze Button’ and Ignoring Football’s ‘Alarm Bells’?
But should we really be that surprised; after all aren’t we all a bit guilty of ignoring the alarm-bells in football? In all honesty the football community (fans included) have repeatedly reached over and ‘hit the snooze button’ when it just isn’t worth the effort to ‘wake up’ and do something either individually or collectively, because it doesn’t directly affect us or ‘our club’.
No one who follows English football should be surprised by the ESL, after all it is in essence just a hybrid of other ‘schemes’ to generate more money from football, and essentially widen the gap between the ‘haves’ and the ‘have nots’.
Isn’t the notion of the European Super League (ESL) just a hybrid
of arguably ‘legitimate’ methods of growing the game?
Isn’t the notion of the ESL just a hybrid of arguably ‘legitimate’ methods of growing the game and in turn generating greater revenues; such as a World Club Cup, ‘39th Game’ and changes to European competitions with more games and stages? Or the more questionable plots such as ‘Project Big Picture’, and in essence the biggest breakaway of them all …… the English Premier League, which in a sense was a domestic super league that benefitted a select group, and over time has widened the gulf to many of those left on the outside trying to get in.
Granted the Premier League has been great for ……., well, ……. the Premier League, a global football audience, investors and those participating in it. However, in essence wasn’t it a seismic event that now leaves us dealing with ever more serious and numerous aftershocks, not least for plans such as the ESL?
Why all the fuss this time?
For me, I firmly believe the reaction of the fans (primarily of those clubs involved in the ESL) is what brought a swift end to the English involvement in the ESL debacle (for now).
Whilst there was undoubted panic amongst those at the Premier League and FA, and many club executives and owners left without a ‘Golden Ticket’ to the ESL party, they didn’t seemingly have any clue of what was really happening. Would there have been as much concern and moaning, and would they have been so reluctant if it had benefitted them and/or they had they been included?
Would there have been as much concern and moaning about the ESL,
if it had benefitted them and/or they had they been included?
This is probably signified best by the pitiful sanctions thus far levied against the Premier Leagues ‘Greedy Six’, which goes to show that the other Premier League clubs (the league and the FA themselves) rely on the six a great deal (if not fear them) and don’t want to punish them too heavily should they be the next ones sanctioned for chasing lucrative returns or wanting to court approval and support for their own ‘plans’.
‘The Game Has Gone’
A cry of frustration expressed by many fans at times is that ‘the game has gone’ and to be quite honest in so many ways it has. It has evolved into a multi-billion-pound global business and we have to accept it is unlikely it will ever be similar to how it used to be.
The selling off of historic stadiums, ‘uber-wealthy’ overseas owners, clubs bought for a pound, takeovers based on leveraged debt and the constantly developing ‘fractures’ in the ‘football pyramid’ leave English football in my view a ‘condemned shell’ of its former self, outside that of the Premier League, (some of) their clubs and the mega-rich owners and investors.
‘fractures’ in the ‘football pyramid’ leave English football
a ‘condemned shell’ of its former self,
The fact is that the Premier League, its superstar players and huge revenues is the ‘expensive wallpaper used to paper over the cracks’ that have not been tended to for quite some time and cause ongoing, recurring and increasingly concerning problems for English Football as a whole (and many of those involved).
Frustrated …… But I am to Blame Like Anyone Else
I have been involved in the game pretty much all of my adult life and grew up a ‘goal kick’ away from the old Wolves training ground, much to the disappointment of my season ticket holding grandfather at Fellows Park, who also was on Walsall’s books in his younger years. I was first involved as a teacher, then coaching junior football, then Saturday non-league management, club secretary and for more than the past 10 years I have been one of those participants many love to hate ………… the scurrilous football agent.
Yet during this time I have constantly strived to seek improvement in the sport and the way it is governed. So why would I say I am to blame? Well the reason is that (like so many) I could have done more, could have been stronger with my views, shown less respect to those (who quite honestly didn’t deserve it) and could have shouted louder and been more confident in pushing forward ideas and concepts that would have helped.
could have done things but chose not to, ignored the warning signs,
the greedy ones and those who quite frankly failed to do their job
This is my motivation for writing this piece (and the ones to follow); a mix of frustrations with people who could have done things but chose not to, those who ignored the warning signs, the greedy ones and those who quite frankly failed to do their job.
In fact, at the time of starting to write this, the England vs Scotland match in Euro 2020 is live on the television in the other room, and sadly I have no will or inclination to watch it …… unlike I did for the likes of Espana 82, Mexico 86, Euro 88, Italia 90, or Euro 96.
The reason for me not watching is that I don’t enjoy watching football like I used to and I wish the England players all the best; BUT the national team I have come to associate with the FA, an organisation I have lost respect for (if not despise) in terms of the professional game and all of their failings and seeming apathy – yet they still clamour for any credit however tenuous a link to successes of the national teams.
No Point in Blame Anymore, We Need Solutions
It is all too easy to point a ‘finger of blame’ and risk being tagged as ‘Captain Hindsight’ without presenting any meaningful solutions or ideas as to what should have been done or could be done, but now is the time to present those ideas and for once not allow others to bury such ideas.
There are many individuals and groups of well-meaning people trying to genuinely make a difference in English football to make such breakaways as the ESL impossible, protect historic clubs going under, and ultimately protect the English ‘football pyramid’.
This could be long standing organisations such as the FSA (Football Supporters Association) or new collectives such as ‘Fair Game’ who all strive to make things better for no other reason than their love of football.
‘HMS Football Utopia’ Has Sailed, if Not Sank
The sad fact is that some of the ideas that have emerged over the years; and more so following the ESL and the sad demise of historic clubs like Bury and Macclesfield, are in my opinion disjointed if not ‘scattergun’. Steered by people whose intentions are good (most of them) but are somewhat skewed at times by unrealistic, academically-driven, de jure, idealism, if not fictional utopian visions with the aim of some form of mass reset in football taking us back in time to the good old days or an unrealistic German style ‘50+1’ club ownership model.
I wish this was in a way possible, but as I said earlier ‘the game has gone’, gone from being the sport of the working class, to a multi-billion-pound global business. To envisage wrestling back control is similar to me expecting to win an arm wrestle with Dwayne ‘The Rock’ Johnson.
The best we can do is try and reign it in, maintain the ‘pyramid’, make football accessible to all, address the interests of ALL stakeholders (meaningfully) and at the very least keep preserving what we ‘have in hand’ and try not to lose any more control.
A Genuine Political Change of Heart, or Populist Policy and Opportunism?
So, who are we looking to, to address these issues, or at the very least help? The resounding answer seems to be a growing reliance on the UK Government. With the Secretary of State for DCMS, Sports Minister, numerous politicians and the Prime Minister ‘piping up’ on the topic of football, following the ESL …. is this concern genuine?
This is largely a group of the same politicians (who with a few exceptions) have either repeatedly made excuses (fuelled by many in the media), stated that they can’t interfere in football as that is ‘Government Interference’, and it is against FIFA rules, “England could be kicked out of the world cup” (as I wrote about several years ago : ‘The ‘Smokescreen’ of Government Interference in Football’), or they are the ones who have just blindly ignored the issues because; they don’t understand, don’t like football or the club in their constituency is (seemingly) alright.
the ‘smokescreen’ of ‘Government Interference’ in football,
has conveniently cleared
The much-heralded solution to all this is …… a ‘review’…… sorry let’s give it its full title – the Governments ‘FAN LEAD Review of Football Governance’. Must get the fans mentioned in this to let them feel included, but arguably there is very limited representation of the fans on the actual panel.
Believe me, I am trying to be positive here but it is increasingly difficult, given the history of the UK Government (and Parliament) in addressing footballs woes.
Whilst we can all draw our own conclusions that Government ‘reviews’ usually:
- take a fair amount of time,
- cost money,
- often end up stating the obvious, and
- ultimately end up achieving nothing
…. we could be excused for choosing not to ‘hold our breath’ in the hope that all of our football concerns will be eradicated and the likes of the ESL will never happen again. As given the false promises, empty threats (directed at the likes of The FA), and feelings of déjà vu over an extended period of repeated football failings and scandals – a large dose of pessimism about meaningful change is justified.
Politicians Have Repeatedly Failed English Football
Added to this, we have to look at the history and track record of the Government and Politicians in addressing football issues. With the exception of a few, most have repeatedly ignored the problems and those who haven’t, have been powerless to do anything.
From DCMS Select Committees regularly highlighting football issues that need to be addressed and calling the likes of the FA and Premier league before them because of another scandal in football (going back many years), to a vote of no confidence in the FA by parliament in 2017, very little has changed. Numerous reviews and enquiries into football related matters, sports ministers arguably covering for football governance bodies and questionable appointments at DCMS relating to football ………… why all the concern now?
In all honesty I was quite optimistic on first hearing Oliver Dowden’s (DCMS Secretary of State) comments about the review following the ESL saga, but over time my optimism has dissipated and I fear this is all just a façade, ‘eyewash’, false promises, platitudes and a token gesture to win votes.
UK Government’s ‘Fan Led Review of Football Governance’ :
a façade, ‘eyewash’, false promises, platitudes
and a token gesture to win votes?
Added to this my heart sank on the news of a former Sports Minister being parachuted in to chair the Fan Led Review of Football Governance, the same minister who not only served as sports minister through many FA and football related crises and scandals, but seemingly also defended the FA time and time again in saying they were reforming and that she (and Government) would act if things didn’t change …… needless to say it didn’t, and we now entrust this crucial role to her.
Plus, there is the rumour that the Prime Minister met with one of the key protagonists in the ESL project just days before it was announced.
I sincerely hope that I am wrong in my perspective on the review and the governments intentions are sincere and true, after so many false dawns in them addressing footballs woes. Yet having tried to engage with Government, Parliament and DCMS on just a small segment of footballs problems with very limited success in getting any meaningful engagement or action, I can’t help but be pessimistic. Whether it be the appointment of woefully informed DCMS civil servants and advisors, a constant merry go round of officials, or endless hearings and reviews that lead to yet more procrastination whilst the problems get more engrained.
Some Apathy, But No Snoozing on Solutions
Sadly, much like my lack of enthusiasm for the England vs Scotland match, I find it difficult to have any enthusiasm to engage with the review. Despite being requested to help a few organisations with their submissions to DCMS and the Review Panel …… I won’t (as many have asked) be submitting evidence directly myself (unless the review proves competent), but I won’t be ‘taking my ball home’ completely.
I don’t have all the answers to football woes, there are far more knowledgeable people than me on specific areas. But neither will I be ‘hitting that snooze button’ on the latest football ‘alarm’ triggered by the ESL.
It is time to present my ideas and concepts loud and proud given the experience and knowledge I have garnered being involved in football for many years, and many of my ideas and opinions on several issues will be detailed in articles to follow.
>>>> Part two of this article, says : ‘The future for English football could be bright …….. with just a hint of orange.
On the topic of ‘Is There Any Light At The End Of The Tunnel For Reform In English Football?‘ – starts to look at the role of UK Government has to play in English Football reform, and whether adopting a Club Licensing System from another European Footballing Nation could be the source of many solutions.
