What makes for a ‘Good’ Football Agent? – Part 2 : ‘Selecting the Good Apples from the Barrel’ on the Player’s Shortlist

As covered in the previous part of this article a football player (and possibly their family) will have had time to select the agent type that they may like to represent them, from no doubt numerous options that they have found, been recommended to them by a club (BEWARE of some of those ‘club’ recommendations), or more than likely the approach from an agent or agency.

FOOTBALL PLAYERS (and their families) MUST REMEMBER:

footballers don’t have to have an agent to sign with a club,
it is a decision for the player to make.


Now, providing those initial hurdles have been considered and overcome, and a shortlist of potential representatives (agents) has been identified (and yes, I mean a list, wherever possible), it is time to get down to the ‘nitty gritty’ and key decisions in who is the right agent for the player formulating how the agent will work for the player.

A footballer shouldn’t rush into signing with a ‘bad’ agent,
wait for the right agent for the player.

No agent, is often better than a bad agent.


Get to Know the Individual (Agent)

Many initial discussions in developing an agent-player relationship understandably revolve around the player and their objectives and expectations – which is a good thing as the player is the client and the talent, and thus the objectives of the relationship should focus on them.

However, what is invariably missed is any evaluation of the agent (in terms of the person), is what ‘makes them tick’, what are their ambitions, motivations and professional experience?

Most importantly, and what I will say once again – there needs to be some commonality between the agent and client (player), as this is essential for an effective working relationship and establishing which agent is ‘good’ for ‘that’ player. It doesn’t necessarily mean they share the same interests, have the same upbringing, or even agree on everything. In fact, I firmly believe that agents should challenge players at times, be a ‘critical friend’, often tell them ‘home truths’ and not just what they want to hear, this is not meant to be a friendship (in a traditional sense), but primarily a working relationship between client (principal) and agent.

developing an agent-player relationship understandably
revolves around the player and their objectives and expectations

Something that does and always has fascinated me about agents is the background as to why they became agents, how they got involved and their professional background. Not least as there are some fascinating stories and many different reasons; all of which give foundations for establishing whether the agent is the right agent for the player-client, a ‘good’ agent, if not even a good person.

I cannot stress this enough, in getting to know the agent as an individual, and I do mean the actual agent. The person who will be representing the player-client, not the assigned ‘face’ of an agency who does all the running around as a ‘front’ for a voice (and if lucky maybe a face) who only gets involved when the next contract offer or transfer materialises with an agent commission attached. The actual person who will countersign the player’s contracts, transfer documents and most importantly answer the player’s phone calls (often at an ungodly hour on seemingly minor, yet important issues) and at all times is there to primarily look after the players best interests.


The Agents ‘Client Base‘

A question that is asked almost inevitably by potential and new clients to an agent (most often by parents) is ‘who else do you represent’, and in all honesty it is a reasonable question …… that is, depending on the reason for asking.

Namely, if the reasoning is to establish the experience of an agent or their standing in the industry then that is perfectly fair, as with any advisor or service provider you would seek to establish their reputation, maybe even seek some references.

‘super players’ don’t always mean ‘super-agents’

However, more often than not it is a is misguided question that invariably triggers some bragging, name-dropping and showmanship, which when used to select an agent based solely on the names of other clients is a bad move.

As I said before ‘super players’ don’t always mean ‘super-agents’ and thus ‘good players’ don’t always mean ‘good agents’. Some of the best agents operate outside of the top leagues, with less well-known player clients, but many of these clients have long, stable, respected and sustained careers often built up over many years with the same agent.


Contracts and the Allowance of Time and Independent Review

Inevitably based on the initial discussions an agent will draft (or have drafted) an initial representation agreement (contract) between the player and the agent, and the key thing here is for the player to take time, review, consider and wherever possible seek independent professional advice.

  • If the agent rushes the player (i.e. to sign), ask why?
  • Is the agreement substantial? – anything less than 3 sides of A4 should be avoided (7 or 8 sides or more is more reasonable).
  • If the player is allowed time to consider the agreement, and if they wish to seek independent and qualified advice (does the agent even suggest the player may want to consider such advice?)
  • To avoid conflicts of interests it should not be an associate or contact of the agent, or even a lawyer (or firm) who also acts as an agent who gives such advice.

Entertain Fair Client (Player) Requests

From my own experience there are many cases where the obligations of both the player and the agent have not been defined in the representation agreement often due to rushing into an agreement. As such this inevitably leads to a breakdown of the relationship, misunderstandings and often disputes that does neither party any favours and which are often avoidable.

Therefore, I believe a good agent should be quite open to clearly define their obligations in any representation agreement with a player, and to work to facilitate any fair and reasonable requests, expectations and objectives of/from the player, within the subsequent agreement.

I would argue that a good, confident and competent agent will quite openly contemplate including such things as (agent) obligations, break clauses, clear payment schedules, exclusivity clauses (e.g., based on geographical coverage) and other measures and clauses with the purpose of enhancing the agreement and the longevity of any subsequent working relationship between player and agent.


Selecting on Performance and the Possibility of Multiple Agents

Over the years I (and I believe many other agents) have had numerous players come to me and state ‘that if I secure them a club/contract/transfer then they will sign with me’. However, from experience this is a ‘sure fire’ way to negate some very ‘good’ agents, as despite whether such a promise from the player is genuine, many agents will have stories of players making such promises only to break the promise and sign with someone else.

Despite this also being in breach of the regulations (something many agents may not even know, recognise or appreciate) it is for me a bad move for a player with many good agents.

a ‘sure fire’ way to negate some very ‘good’ agents,
and a breach of football regulations

I understand why players do it, I really do. They are about to assign an important role in the development and management of their career to a relatively unknown person for a period of anything up to 2 years. There are countless stories of players signing a representation contract with an agent, only to see or hear from them a few times in the ensuing period, and with little or no productive effort in the interests of the player.

This matter is as frustrating for ‘good’ agents as it is for players, as there are numerous examples of footballing careers that have been setback years or totally destroyed by an agent’s neglect.

I do believe however that there are possibilities for a player to potentially protect themselves from such agent neglect when selecting an agent:

  • Clearly define the obligations of the agent in the representation agreement.
  • Make the agreement short term to begin with.
  • Restrict the coverage of the agent (eg.to a specific country, league, region)
  • OR BEST OF ALL a combination of all three of the above

Some agents won’t like this approach, but for those genuine agents who really want to represent the player and are confident in their ability to do so, they won’t dismiss such an approach.

However, I am confident it will identify the ‘cowboys’ and the time-wasters will be gone, or the player will be better protected from them.


Gifts and Incentives (possible bribes?)

It has become seemingly commonplace in the football industry for the offering and acceptance of certain ‘inducements’ and ‘gifts’, including between agents and players (and their family members and ‘advisors’).

Given that such activity is arguably common and to an extent expected, does not make it right, whether this be under football regulations or the law. Arguably in the UK it may even mean such an act makes it illegal (under the bribery act) whether accepting, soliciting, offering such a bribe.

not just a breach of football regulations,
but also potentially a criminal offence

In light of such changes to legislation, both inside and outside of football, I would discourage any player (family member etc) from entertaining such activity whether as recipient or facilitator and as such any agent doing the same should be avoided, however substantial such a ‘gift’ may be.

If an agent offers (or entertains) such incentives it invariably means the amount spent on such is being regained somewhere else, most likely from the player (either directly or indirectly).

Likewise, no player (family member or associate) should pass any incentive to the agent with a view to forming such a working relationship, beyond that of a fair commission once the agent has done their job and fulfilled their obligations (in full) to the player.


‘Trainee‘ Football Agents

The ‘profession’ (allegedly) of the football agent, no doubt in the minds of some, conjures up an image of glamour, a ‘jet setting‘ lifestyle, a new Range Rover for each day of the week, supercars and luxury – how wrong they are. With that, it attracts a lot of ‘wannabe’ football agents for a whole range of reasons, some good and some bad.

Probably from this misconception, a new term seems to have crept into the football industry in recent times and this is ‘Trainee Football Agent’. These people may well be developed from a whole raft of agent courses/qualifications (some good, some not so good) that have sprung up since 2015, but how qualified or legitimate are they?

There is no such thing as a ‘Trainee’ football agent
under the current regulations,

either an agent is authorised by the football authorities
or they are not!

In essence, much the same as any other agent, they may be good or bad, may work for a large agency or operate independently.

However, what I would say to any player is that there is no such thing as a ‘trainee football agent’ in terms of the knowledge, experience and most importantly ‘authorisation’ to represent a player. Go back to my first suggestion, check if they are registered with the National Association, if not they should not be operating as an agent, and invariably players should NOT be working with them.


In Summary

For me a good agent is one who aims to at all times to represent the best interests of their clients (even above the agents own interests) and works to jointly achieve the clients aims and objectives (within reason); and within the applicable laws and regulations.

These aims and objectives may well change over time and subsequently players often change agents (sometimes the agent’s choice, I hasten to add), not always for the scurrilous reasons that are often rumoured or even reported. Quite often agents and players remain confidents long after the professional association has ended, which for me is one of the signs of a good agent.

This should be the case whether it be a player who wants to reach the heights of representing their country, carve out a long career in football at a modest level, earn megabucks and have the showbiz lifestyle or even just a young player who wants to get the chance to sign a professional contract with their hometown club

……. there is no ‘one size fits all’ when it comes to a ‘good’ agent,

 but there are ways to sort out the ‘potentially’ good agents from the ‘potentially’ bad ones.


<<<< Part one of this article : Footballers Don’t Need a Super Agent, Just a Good Agent – Part 1 : Shortlisting A Good Agent – looked at the general principles of what makes a good football agent ….

  • Authorised and regulated or unlicensed
  • Big agency or independent agent
  • The rise of the ‘super agent’
  • Famous or Infamous
  • Basic Knowledge
  • And developing a ‘shortlist’ of possible agents for the player


You may also like...