When All Else Fails, Should FIFPRO & Ultimately the Players License ‘Player Agents’ in Football?

The seemingly perpetual impasse, procrastination and stalling of the new regulations and licensing for football agents needs a conclusion for the benefit of all involved.

Whilst in conversation with a professional associate in the last week or so, we inevitably got onto the topic of the licensing and regulation of football agents, as we always do, given the seemingly perpetual impasse, procrastination and disagreement that currently engulfs the implementation of new Football Agent Regulations (FFAR) by FIFA.

Should FIFPRO & Ultimately the Players License 'Player Agents' in Football

As such, we both acknowledged the importance of FIFPRO and their national member organisations (e.g. the PFA in England) in this regards to agent licensing. Not least for the fact that it is key to their members, and I would argue that they are the football stakeholder group (player) most affected by the activity of football agents.

Yet there seems to be a lack of clarity as to where the player representative organisations/associations (e.g. FIFPRO) stand in terms of the agent licensing debate and what changes they wish to see. Whether this be an unwillingness to publicly ‘nail their colours to the mast’, disagreement between the various associations or the matter (yet unlikely) that they just don’t care or want to share any of the responsibility for this area.


‘Football Agents’ or ‘Player Agents‘

As I have covered in past articles, one of the key and most problematic changes for me with the new proposed FFAR (FIFA Football Agent Regulations), is the change in terminology from ‘Player Agents’ to ‘Football Agents’, and whether this is dismissed by others as a minor issue or even a linguistic or semantic oversight …… I truly see it as a key issue, and it conflicts with what was presumed to be the original role of ‘agents’ in football (i.e. to protect the interests of the player).

Regarding the matter that FIFA now seemingly sees agents as ‘football agents’ rather than a primary role as ‘player agents’ in the past (pre-2015), this should I believe, be an ‘alarm-bell’ to the likes of FIFPRO, player associations and the players themselves. In that (and FIFA seemingly acknowledge), the interests of the ‘player’ as the client are no longer necessarily at the forefront of a ‘football agent’ duties as they are (or at least implied) with a ‘player agent’.

If the notion is implied by footballs ‘world governing body’ that they readily accept agents represent multiple parties in a transaction, and that the player’s interests aren’t necessarily a priority for the agent (either directly or indirectly), we could well see the activities of ‘football agents’ be even less focussed on the interests of the players (arguably the football stakeholder group most significantly affected by agents).


Truth or Rumour

Depending on whom you speak to in regards to what FIFPRO and their member Player Associations want to see implemented in regards to the regulation of agents in football, you will hear various pieces of information as well as a fair dose of myth and rumour.

As I understand it there has been no ‘official’ dialogue between FIFPRO and the agent associations on the matter of agent licensing, regulation and FFAR; not least for the reasons I explained in a recent blog about the lack of ‘official’ representation of agents – Why haven’t football agents got a credible and legitimate voice as a football stakeholder? Is legitimacy & credibility something they and others in football truly desire?.

There is no doubting that FIFPRO has been involved in the consultation process with FIFA over the new FFAR, however it is difficult to ascertain what aspects they wanted, supported or even objected to in any new licensing and agent regulations that have been proposed. This has inevitably left a vacuum for rumours, a key one of which is that allegedly FIFPRO and some of the Player Associations wish to operate as agents themselves.


FIFpro and Player Associations Wish to Become Agents – Truth or Rumour?

From speaking to those in the agent community it seems a firmly held belief that under the new agent regulations (FFAR), the likes of FIFPRO and the National Player Association want to be able to operate as agents (agencies) themselves, either directly or indirectly.

Whilst some may argue this away as a ‘myth’, I believe there is some legitimacy in this assessment, not least as it has not been officially denied. But also, from examining the various drafts of the FFAR from FIFA, there have been amendments to both restrict such an arrangements and then subsequently reverse it. Hence, with the final FFAR draft from FIFA it does appear that amendments will arguably allow for an officer, employee or representative from the likes of FIFPRO or a national player association to operate as an agent.

Player Associations as Agents is Nothing New

Whilst this is a concern for most (if not all) agents with the influence and direct access that player associations have to players, many are surprised to find that some agents in England (whilst objecting) are seemingly unperturbed by the notion.

The reason for this, is that in England the national players association (The PFA) has operated in effect a connected agency arm under the guise of the PMA for many years, and as such, agents in England have become accustomed (yet opposed) to this.

However, in becoming accustomed to this ‘threat’ has also embedded a certain amount of acrimony, mistrust and contempt between the two; which in my view has primarily been to the detriment of players who cannot utilise two ‘communities’ who are both there ultimately to help players as clients/members and in effect, if working together without any conflicts of interest, would further benefit the player.

So, would spreading the ‘player association agent’ methodology to a broader market benefit the players or be to their detriment?  I would safely predict the latter.

Player Associations as Agents

The debate as to whether player associations should represent players as their agents is a topic in itself and the arguments both for and against can become quite complex, but as a brief example:

  • Is a salaried employee of a player association going to be as motivated to work 24/7 for a player client in exchange for missing their child’s school play, travelling endlessly, answering the phone at 3.30 in the morning for a minor issue or cutting their family holiday short?

    Whereas an agent, whose bottom line, relationship with the player and reputation is on the line will ultimately make such concessions in a sacrifice for reward model.
  • Is there a greater risk of conflicts of interest for a player association, that is meant to represent all of its members equally – e.g. in such cases of a transfer, trial or contract.
  • Will such association agent operations become an ‘incubator’ – for agents who then leave the association to become independent agents, thus eroding the original objective?
  • The operations of player associations as agents are far from faultless (as with independent agents), with cases of them being sanctioned for breaches of the regulations.
  • The indirect detriment to players; as the relationship between agents and player associations becomes more challenging if not acrimonious and mistrusting.

Whether it be motivation, conflicts of interest, or performance; from my own experience and observations, the allowance for player associations to operate as agents is ultimately to the detriment of the players for a plethora of reasons, not least the division and mistrust between player association and the agent, which has been noticeable in English football for many years.


Should the Players (collectively as FIFPRO and Associations) License Agents?

Ultimately it is the case (or should be) that the individual player ‘in effect’ licenses their agent; they sign the representation agreement and then entrust their interests to that agent/agency or agents.

So, on that basis is it so inconceivable that the player associations look to license those who wish to act as agents from a player representative perspective? Once again I will reiterate; isn’t it the key underlying principle that the player associations are there to represent the interests of their members as the priority?

Yet, herein lies a potentially uncomfortable yet unavoidable truth that pushes player/member interests to the periphery in football, and that is power, politics and finance. Would the likes of FIFPRO and the player associations ‘pushing’ for the right to license agents (if not enforce sanctions) damage their relationship with if not hugely irritate FIFA, and what would be the implications?


A ‘Marriage of Convenience’? – FIFA and FIFPRO

It is not inconceivable to envisage that some sort of trade-off has been agreed between FIFA and FIFPRO in regards to the proposed FFAR? This is not least a fair presumption given that there is little or no information on their discussions behind what has effectively been ‘closed doors’, and also the various changes in the proposed draft regulations (FFAR) over the last couple of years that would determine whether player association officials/employees would be able to act as licensed ‘football agents’.

Power and Politics

It has understandably been a difficult couple of years for FIFA, as FIFA 2.0 tries to rebuild the reputation of the organisation and the undertakings of previous regimes. As such, it is both important that they seemingly keep control of world football whilst also keeping key stakeholders ‘on side’ such as FIFpro (and subsequently the players and their associations).

On this basis, it would be difficult to see FIFA not give FIFPRO an ‘attentive ear’ and also allow them some leeway in terms of the new FFAR; such as allowing FIFPRO and Player Associations to operate as agent/agencies. Arguably this would afford the likes of FIFPRO and their member associations additional revenue streams and may subsequently reduce any such financial pressures on FIFA.

Finance

I have attempted to decipher the source of FIFPRO’s revenues, as from my perspective I long believed this came from member associations, but depending on whom you speak to they have differing assumptions as to the source of FIFpro’s finances.

After speaking to members of the media, player representatives, finance professionals, agents and many others (including FIFPRO officials) it is still pretty inconclusive as to how FIFPRO is funded. However, many believe a significant amount of their funding allegedly comes from FIFA, and as such FIFPRO may understandably be fearful of ‘biting the hand that feeds’ should they try to stretch their remit to such things as the licensing of player agents.

If this is the case, I would counter such an argument that in imposing a small levy on agent’s fees they would increase their revenues as well as any ‘player-agent’ licensing fees. Also, it cannot be argued that a large proportion (if not the greatest) of power in football is with the players (subsequently FIFPRO); as without them, there is no game.


Conclusion

Now in reading this article, please don’t misunderstand me in my impression of FIFPRO; who for many years I had viewed as probably the most anti-agent body in the world of football. FIFPRO representatives have delivered some of the most damning rhetoric against football agents I have experienced, which was in many cases unjustified and incorrect in my opinion. Subsequently, it is understandable why there is mistrust towards their intentions and aims from the football agent community, even from the more ‘moderate’ elements like myself.

However, in the last few years, it has appeared to me that FIFPRO (and some of the player associations) have softened their tone towards agents, and some have almost accepted the important role that legitimate agents play.

Or am I just being naïve here and missing the fact that as some suspect, is this merely a ploy in a ‘long game’?

The simple fact is however that this is not a binary conclusion as to whether the likes of FIFPRO should license ‘player agents’, there are pro’s and con’s to the issue and for this allowance there needs to be various caveats applied, rules imposed, responsibilities undertaken and most importantly concessions made for such a proposal to be a success.

The Case Against

Looking pragmatically at the proposal as to whether FIFPRO (and player associations) should license player agents in football, my biggest reservation is that it potentially fractures football regulations yet further as to who writes the regulations, who enforces them and who imposes sanctions, in an industry that badly needs cohesion for improvement of regulation. Hence ‘fracturing’ this element of regulation further may well weaken the implementation of effective regulations.

The introduction of the RWWI (Regulations on Working with Intermediaries) introduced by FIFA in 2015 and arguably the regulations before RWWI have resulted in a largely unregulated industry full of confusion, failed regulation and meaningless sanctions, and with the latest FFAR I fear sadly this will again be the case for years to come.

So, can the industry and the football community as a whole afford yet more fractured regulation with the introduction of another organisation into the regulatory process?

The Case For

Whilst many may cite the cases of ‘player’ associations successfully licensing (if not regulating) player agents, most notably in the USA with the NFL and NBA, this is in many cases not directly transferable to the world of Association Football; given the structures of US sport (e.g. franchise models and CBAs) and the sports geographic remit and applicable laws.

However, what it does demonstrate is that such player organisations can effectively license agents and play a crucial part in the regulatory process, thus sharing the burden, should boundaries of jurisdiction and responsibility be clearly defined.

The fact is, that player associations such as FIFPRO (and its member associations) have a primary role in representing the interests of players (as members) and whilst ‘player’ agents have a similar duty to players as clients, the licensing of such agents should arguably be in the hands of the same organisation. Not least the influence that the likes of FIFPRO and its members could directly apply in the area of agent regulations would assist not just its members, but also FIFA and the wider footballing world.

At Fear of Repeating Myself – A Shared Responsibility

As I have written (and spoken about) on many occasions in the past, the licensing of agents by the likes of FIFA and national football associations has largely been a failure for an unacceptably prolonged period of time, and I believe that will continue to be the case under the proposed FFAR, scheduled (at the time of writing) to be approved in June/July 2022 (not just for the reasons explained in this article).

Maybe it is time to share the burden of the licensing and regulation of football agents, with the likes of FIFPRO licensing ‘player agents’ (not generic ‘football agents’ or ‘club agents’), and working WITH legitimate ‘player-agents’ in the interest of their members (players and player associations), FIFA and the wider football community as a whole.

You may also like...