Is There Any Light At The End Of The Tunnel For Reform In English Football? (pt 3)
If UK Government really cared about football reform what can they do? …… evolution, not revolution.
I discussed in the previous article the KNVBs (Club) Licensing Model in the Netherlands as the means to underpin any meaningful reform to address some of the problems and potential threats to English football. The conclusion was that such a licensing system would help English Football reform a great deal if not resolve many problematic issues and threats, however it would be seemingly flawed without the backing of UK government.
Yet over the years of reading various Hansard documents, watching Parliamentary debates, Commons Select Committee hearings and also dealing both directly and indirectly with Government, Parliamentary and Governance individuals and departments on the issues of football governance and reform, there just seems to either be a large amount of apathy on the subject, or dare I say that many involved lack the knowledge, foresight or vision on what can, should, or could be done.
football governance reform is flawed
without the backing of UK government
I totally accept that politicians (and civil servants) like anyone else will not have all the answers. Despite football arguably being the biggest sport in the UK; it is still understandable that many people either don’t like football, don’t understand it or don’t appreciate it, let alone have a passion for it …… and in essence, those groups as a collective are more than likely the majority.
Diluting Progress with Too Many Voices,
Fuelled by Subjectivity Rather Than Objectivity
Over the years I have heard a plethora of ideas as to how English football should be reformed. Granted a lot of these have been left to ‘flounder on the rocks’ whilst others have been conveniently ‘side-lined’, if not silenced by others whose motives and agendas aren’t always progressive.
With the ESL (European Super League), the impact of covid (from which football I believe still hasn’t yet seen the full impact) and the demise of historic clubs such as Bury; this ‘tsunami’ of well-intentioned ideas, concepts and opinions has continued. Some ideas are new and some are just old and repackaged; some come with an underlying agenda and some are totally unbiased and well meaning, some from academia and some from business, some naïve and some arguably ‘blinkered’ (if not idiotic).
As have stated in previous articles, ‘I don’t have all the answers’, but I do fear that any meaningful reform in football is in danger of being diluted with ideas and opinions fuelled by naivety, idealism and subjectivity. All of which are acceptable mistakes to make given the historic, genealogical and emotional ties many have with football.
meaningful reform in football is in danger of being diluted
by naivety, idealism and subjectivity
So, with that in mind I have decided in this article just to highlight a few of the effective measures I do believe would be productive and practical for UK Government to support and implement (if not legislate on) to maximise the chances of effective reform in English football and underpin the idea of a (club) Licensing System in English football, similar to that in the Netherlands.
** Please note I have tried to focus more on the ‘carrot’ than the ‘stick’
Legislation for Football Evolution, Not Revolution
GBEs, Visas and Work Permits
Again, I will state here I am not an immigration lawyer or expert on such matters but I do understand a fair bit on how this aspect works in football (given my work with Football Authorities and advising players and clubs).
As it stands GBE’s (Governing Body Endorsements) are applied for through the FA by English football clubs wishing to be granted work permits/visas enabling staff from overseas (e.g., players, coaches) to be employed by the club in the UK.
The applications have to meet a certain set of criteria to be granted a GBE by the FA, which is then sanctioned by the Home Office and a work permit/visa granted. In exceptional circumstances it may be granted on appeal by the sponsoring-club/employer, should the original application not meet the criteria/points required.
football recruitment and visas
could become reliant on reform & football club licensing
The GBE system for the granting of work-permits/visas used in tandem with that of a football (club) licensing system, could in effect allow licensed clubs to have a preferential set of criteria over those unlicensed clubs (thus encouraging clubs to be licensed).
This, therefore, makes football (club) licensing an integral part of a football club’s strategy in being able to recruit the best footballing and executive staff from overseas (especially prevalent as more English football clubs have international ownership and investment).
Broadcasting (Rights)
It is difficult to argue that the broadcast rights (and the revenue streams that accompany them) have been the major driving force behind the growth of the English Premier League, and the financial strength of the clubs; whilst also being the cause of the growing divide between footballs ‘haves’ and the ‘have nots’.
As such, ‘broadcasting’ rights are, I believe, a major ‘bargaining chip’ in the reform of football and football governance; and an area where the UK Government has the ability to ‘flex its muscles’ (if it wishes to) in underpinning such a Football (club) licensing system.
Needless to say, that with the advent of other mediums and potential broadcast partners emerging (e.g., Amazon, Netflix, Google, Facebook) as well as international broadcasting rights and unlicensed ‘pirate’ broadcasters, it is very difficult to control where or by whom English Football and the likes of the Premier League is broadcast, both legally and illegally.
However, in terms of underpinning and reinforcing an English Football (club) Licensing model, the UK Government and in turn OFCOM, with the likes of the ‘Code of Sports and Other Listed and Designated Events’ legislation, which I believe to be part of the ‘Broadcasting Act 1996’, can exercise leverage in favour of football governance reform.
‘unlicensed’ football clubs
may have to make their matches
‘free to air’ in the UK
Whilst I believe the government arguably couldn’t justify legislating on the ability of a club (as a private entity) to broadcast its matches, I do believe it possible for legislation under the ‘Code of Sports and Other Listed and Designated Events’ to make any events or sports it deems fit, available via free-to-air tv channels in the UK (as is the case with the likes of the FIFA World Cup, the FA Cup Final, the Grand National and The Olympics).
Therefore, legislation may be able to dictate that all professional football clubs in England who are ‘unlicensed’ have to make the broadcasting of their matches (which are broadcast in any form) ‘free to air’ in the UK.
Therefore, creating leverage (if only on UK broadcasting rights), by the broadcasting rights being significantly increased for the club if licensed, whilst also benefitting supporters who will be able to watch such matches free of subscription costs for any clubs who are unlicensed.
Wider Implications of Football (Club) Licensing
Whilst the Licensing System in the Netherlands was developed with an emphasis on ‘Financial Stability’ for its member clubs, it stretches far beyond that. It encompasses far more football related aspects than just finance; such as fan engagement, legal aspects, club organisation, communities and infrastructure.
It acts as a means of recognition/praise, warning, assistance and if absolutely necessary, punishment for clubs. Yet, it does one other important thing; in that it is proactive in addressing issues and adapting for the benefit of all football stakeholders, rather than reactive when problems have spiralled out of control (e.g. ‘MPs left ‘stunned’ after FA Chairman admits FA only intervened in Bury crisis a month after club had already collapsed’).
The ‘F’ Word
At risk of tarnishing the concept of the ‘club license’ I will use the dreaded ‘F’ word for European football – ‘FRANCHISE’!
In essence, the licensing system is NOT a franchise model, but in a way, it is kind of similar, in that whilst being an ‘asset’ to the club, the license is not owned by the club but loaned on a conditional basis by the authorities.
The license comes with obligations, but it also comes with rewards for the bearer, that in turn enhances other assets including their potential value.
‘Fit and Proper’ Persons (Owners and Directors Test)
As such the vision for such a ‘license’ in English football would be that when an entity relinquishes control of a club (i.e., sold), the license is revoked for that entity (owner), as it is in essence ‘non-transferable’. Thus, for a new entity/owner to continue operations at the club, they would need to be approved in advance by the authorities, and the club granted a ‘new license’.
By having such a ‘licensing’ safeguard in place, the value of the club until a new license is provisionally approved to a prospective new ownership entity, would be diminished for both the old and new controlling entity.
non-transferable football club licensing,
safeguarding clubs against unfit owners
In turn, this would address issues experienced historically in English football whereby control of a football club has been relinquished by one part to another without the new party being approved by the football authorities.
The ‘Owner and Directors’ (fit and proper) Test draws a lot of criticism from many for its effectiveness. Yet whether the actual test is effective or not, is not for me to really judge, I would however say the way in which the test is implemented at the moment, is a flawed exercise. Such an approach puts clubs at the mercy of asset strippers and opportunists, and is a worthless exercise as the club has already changed hands (often for a solitary pound) even before the ‘Owners and Directors’ checks have been completed.
‘Cannibal Turkeys‘ in Control
In most industries and professions there is a governing body, one who stands in authority, sets out rules and enforces them with no conflict of interest. Yet for me (and no doubt many others) this has become skewed in English Football, with the constant fracturing of football and the so called ‘English Football Pyramid’.
We now have a situation at the top level of English football whereby there are 3 entities all vying for control; which depending on your role and interests, any one could be the one adjudged to be in control.
The FAs position has been arguably weakened over the years, along with the respect many hold for it (myself included). Yes, the FA is still the National Governing Body (NGB) for football but arguably this is just in name, and in essence from a professional game perspective this is retained under the auspices of UEFA and FIFA.
Meanwhile we have the Premier League and EFL, one unarguably richer than the other, yet the other has more members and is a crucial body in English Football.
who is really in charge of English football?
where are the ‘custodians’ of English football?
So, in light of the fact that the NGB (the FA) has now seemingly lost the will, influence or even power to ‘Govern’, and the leagues are still in essence (and always have been), competition organisers ………. who is really in charge of English Football and looking out for its interests?
A lot is spoken about clubs not having owners but ‘custodians’ of the club, as once the ‘owners’ have moved on the fans will remain as (hopefully) will the club. Yet have many of us lost sight as to who are now the ‘custodians’ of English football, free of conflicts of interest and focussed on ‘sustainability’ rather than ‘profitability’.
Well, the rules of the Premier League are approved by its members and the rules of the EFL are approved by its members ……. their members are ………… the clubs. Decisions effectively made by the owners, so can we really expect self-regulating bodies to apply and enforce meaningful reform in football or is this just again ‘turkeys voting for Christmas’.
So, can footballs house really expect to be in good working order with an absentee landlord, tenants who write their own rules and are constantly in competition …………. the simple answer is no.
Licensing Taken One Step Further –
Not Just Clubs, But Leagues and Competitions
From my perspective, the licensing system could indeed go one step further and impose a license for professional leagues and competitions (in addition to clubs). This will in essence remove the barrier of ‘turkeys having to vote for Christmas’ and bring into play a collective responsibility.
Hopefully resulting in an environment free from ineffective reforms and self-regulation, one league using leverage over another, insider dealing between clubs, lack of transparency and ultimately giving overall authority through licensing to a meaningful governing body.
But that in itself brings us back to an outstanding problem and question to answer ……. Who governs English Football?
Governing Body, Regulator or Commission
Irrelevant of the terminology used; whether it be a regulator, commission or something else, football in England badly needs an independent body to oversee the sport to try and reassert some semblance of fairness, stability, integrity and TRUE TRANSPARENCY for a sport that has been developed for communities over many many years.
Yet this again is something many (including myself) have campaigned for over many years. So, in the next article I will look at how an Independent Football Regulator (supported by UK Government) would be implemented within English footballs structures, and also the role it would play in righting English Football’s Fractured and badly listing pyramid.
On the topic of ‘Is There Any Light At The End Of The Tunnel For Reform In English Football?‘ – looks at The Problem of English Football’s ‘Fractured’ and Badly ‘Listing’ Pyramid.
<<<< Part Two (2) of this article, says : ‘The future for English football could be bright …….. with just a hint of orange. >>>>>
On the topic of ‘Is There Any Light At The End Of The Tunnel For Reform In English Football?‘ – starts to look at the role of UK Government has to play in English Football reform, and whether adopting a Club Licensing System from another European Footballing Nation could be the source of many solutions.
