40,000+ Words on the Viability of Proposals & Proposed Resolutions for Football Agent Regulations …..why?
Because After 4 Years of Impasse & Arguments, It’s Time for Resolutions and Progress
After a few months in composition, segmented by an unwanted stay in hospital, 41,000 words later I finally managed it, and completed what I have called a ‘white paper’ looking at the implementation of the latest draft regulations (3rd version at the time of writing) for the new FIFA Football Agent Regulations (FFAR).
It took some convincing to actually do it, many people have suggested I do so over the years. Yet, following some convincing by a friend and professional associate from the sports law world and the fact that this week FIFA Congress are reportedly due to discuss (if not approve) the new FFAR, there seemed no better time to finally put ‘pen to paper’.
Why the Delay, and Lack of Motivation?
Even though so many different people over the years have encouraged me to compose such a document, it is something I have always been reluctant to do (preferring shorter articles and blogs), believing that there are so many people far more knowledgeable than myself on the topic. Believing that they may also be far more creative and capable to look at things in a considered, sensible and pragmatic way, enabling them to come up with required solutions and improvements for the ‘football agent industry’ and publish them.
Yet it seems I was wrong in doubting my own ability, knowledge and many years of experience operating in the football agent industry, campaigning for better (more effective and fairer) regulations, working with the football authorities on regulations, consulting with government departments and also being an official for agent bodies.
I was wrong in the fact that I believed those in a position to create, lobby and implement such change and improvements were able to do so, willing to do so or open-minded enough to even consider them. Maybe in my own naivety, I should have attempted to ‘read the room’ better; after submitting concepts (some of which are in the new ‘white paper’ document) to some of these supposed industry influencers; that it seems in reality weren’t interested in improvement, didn’t have the true means to influence change (as they presented) or had an agenda or political interests that superseded such concepts for improvements for stakeholders and participants as a whole.
Don’t Believe What You Hear or Read
Another reason for me choosing to release such a document is the amount of misinformation in the media on the topic of the new FFAR. Whilst I am the first one to admit some of the sports media aren’t known for letting the facts get in the way of a bit of sensationalism, it seems on many occasions that they have often been ‘spun a line’ on this topic to suit someone else’s agenda or narrative on the story; whether it be agents, clubs, leagues or supposed ‘sources’ within FIFA, football authorities or ‘stakeholder’ groups/organisations.
Now for the ‘DISCLAIMER’: I must clarify that I don’t believe I know what is truly going on with all the mixed messages, confusion and deliberate misinformation that is circulating on the topic of the new FIFA football agent regulations (FFAR). At the risk of seeming arrogant, I do believe I have a better idea than most, as over the years I have been pretty good at predicting the timeline and also pre-empting the actions and motivations of various people and groups involved in the process of football agent regulations (including the most recent FFAR process).
I have my suspicions on the various agendas that may exist for some and also how things may ‘pan out’ moving forward. But even if I was allowed to bet on football-related matters, I wouldn’t stake anything on the outcome of this saga ………. beyond that of the current situation on its current course being an absolute disaster.
‘Clear eyes, full hearts, open minds, can’t lose’
In somewhat plagiarising the phrase ‘clear eyes, full hearts, can’t lose’ from a sports-related TV show, I believe the four years of seeming ‘impasse’ on the implementation of new football agent regulations is not down to a lack of willingness or effort, but just a misdirection of energy on the parts of many.
I won’t dwell on this too much, as I have covered it in other articles as to where I believe the responsibilities lie for the lack of effective regulation and professional behaviour in the football agent industry.
But referring back to the phrase, in not having:
- ‘Clear eyes’ – to put things into perspective, to see what is important and seeing the viewpoint of others.
- ‘Full hearts’ – empathy, rather than harbouring past grievances & a focus on self-interest (that may ultimately be self-destructive)
- ‘Open minds’ – to accept new ideas and not focus on preconceptions or a fixed narrative, mantra or mindset
……. the outcome won’t be the desired ‘can’t lose’; but a case of ‘will lose’ (for almost everyone).
The Devil is In the Detail
The term ‘excessive’ is something that has frustrated me on this topic for several months, and as I have long stated, judging what is ‘excessive’ is a
When I started drafting the document, I set a target (if not limit) of probably 4000 to 5000 words, but as I started ‘digging deeper’ into the subject, going back into the archives, searching my own memory bank and looking at the underlying issues, the ‘white paper’ grew and grew …………. hence there are 2 versions of the document:
- The main document ‘white paper’
- The summary document
The summary document was composed to allow readers to quickly look at the key issues that are proving such areas of consternation and objection with the new FFAR (including the main hurdle of a ‘cap’ on agent service fees). These are the issues believed to pose the greatest threat to the effective implementation of much needed improved regulations for the football Agent industry.
In addition to that, they are also the key issues that are very likely (if not inevitable) to bring about legal action against FIFA from various parties around the world, should the new FFAR be approved and/or implemented.
The summary document does not however cover such things as the underlying issues, the recent history of agent regulation or examine some of the justifications given for the implementation of such things as a ‘cap’ – whereas the main document does cover these areas and examines considerations from various points of view on the proposed new FFAR.
To truly understand my thought processes (on the topic), the underlying issues, considerations and evidence/experience that allowed me to come to some of the conclusions, anyone reading the summary document must also look at the main ‘white paper’ (and its 41,000 words) to understand.
End Goal – Consideration & Compromise, Rather than Litigation & Damage Limitation
So, what is my aim in taking so long to compose this document?
Well from a totally selfish point of view it may open up a future opportunity for me in being able to ‘play my part’ in addressing such issues, but that was not the aim or intention.
Although towards the end of the writing process it became quite ‘tiresome’ and had an element of melancholy (e.g., looking back on past failings, efforts, missed opportunities). Yet, I have to thank my friend (D) who convinced me to do it as the process was quite cathartic and ultimately led to a feeling of ‘closure’ (and ‘getting it off my chest’).
However, if there is a primary set of objectives to come from this, it is that it promotes awareness and discussion amongst those in the football community that it affects and thus gives the opportunity for new regulations to be implemented for football agents that come from compromise, understanding and consideration rather than impasse and ultimate conflict.
Links to the ‘White Paper Document’:
- Main ‘White Paper’ Document
https://bit.ly/FootballAgentWhitePaper-V1pv
OR
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1tyQ7GrfdmxfxvMxhJGu5vYdNdTxrcM1p/view?usp=sharing
- Lower Res Version
https://bit.ly/FootballAgentWhitePaper-V1lr
OR
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1nFGSZfWncvLvn82mjzhwqUXtCTVeHF3k/view?usp=sharing
- ‘White Paper’ Summary Document
https://bit.ly/FootballAgentWhitePaper-Summary-V1pv
OR
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1lML2EwMGFAqWj8QnOjEHNNYfI6pbBBbI/view?usp=sharing
- Lower Res Version
https://bit.ly/FootballAgentWhitePaper-Summary-V1lr
OR
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1COiRfHD69avK1ndwieAKe90dwso_xmVc/view?usp=sharing
