Is the ‘Capping’ of Football Agent’s Fees the Biggest Hurdle to a More Professional Industry? (PART 1)
Even as an agent I find it near impossible to defend some agents who take huge commissions, and in all honesty, I (like many other agents) view this as unacceptable and somewhat of a ‘plague‘ to football, but sadly (and unfairly) all agents are seemingly labelled all the same.
In fact, I would openly admit some of the fees paid to football agents are astronomical and seemingly unjust if not out of control. That is not to say that a football agent who secures their player client a lucrative contract does not deserve a lucrative commission, they do, but it must be fair, proportionate and in their client’s best interests.
FIFA’s Proposed ‘Capping’ of Football Agent Commissions
As you may (or may not) be aware, it is the intention of FIFA to reintroduce the football agents license and with it new and improved regulations governing football agents and their activities.
Subsequently one of the reported key foundations of these proposals and understandably one of the most contentious areas, is that of a ‘cap’ on agent’s fees, which whilst getting support from many (both informed and ill-informed), it has also generated a large amount of resistance.
improving the football agent industry could be jeopardised,
by the issue of ‘capping’ football agents fees.
The worrying thing is that with FIFAs good intentions of improving an industry that drastically needs improvement, I fear any progression with these improvements will be hung up on this one issue of the ‘capping’ football agent’s fees.
In fact, I fear (as in 2015) this will be a hurdle that not just FIFA, but the football industry as a whole cannot overcome and may result in the failure of new regulations, a new license and subsequently limited improvement (if any) in the football agent industry, for ALL affected.
FIFA’s Agent Commission ‘Cap’ of 2015
It is no secret that FIFA (both the new regime, and past regimes) have discussed and seemingly been encouraged by various groups (e.g. clubs, player unions, club associations) to introduce a ‘cap’ on agents fees for many years, and in 2015 (and the preceding years) they came close to implementing such measures.
Before the introduction (1st April 2015) of the arguably useless and misguided ‘Regulations on Working with Intermediaries’ from the ‘old FIFA’, there was seemingly great intent from FIFA to introduce a 3% cap on agents fees in these new regulations. This predictably generated huge resistance from agent groups around the world and potentially legal challenges to both FIFA and some national football associations.
So, what happened to this ‘cap’? Well, it is, as I write this article, still in various forms of the current (intermediary/agent) regulations. However, the end result is seemingly something very different to what FIFAs original intentions were and their earlier drafts of the 2015 regulations.
Eventually, what was implemented in the final regulations was an ‘advisory cap’ or guideline to say the agent’s fee/commission ‘should not exceed three per cent (3%)’. Needless to say; was it really worth all the delays, arguments, bickering and legal threats that resulted in this pointless outcome?
Although not directly on the ‘front line’ at the time, as General Secretary of one of the Football Agent Associations, I was privy to some of what was going on and the discussions behind the scenes between various groups and individuals (including FIFA, agent groups and other stakeholders).
confusion over FIFA’s agent’s fee ‘cap’ in 2015 –
some FIFA officials didn’t even know what it was.
The amount of confusion and misinformation circulating at this time was probably best demonstrated when a former FIFA representative who was apparently involved in the drafting of the 2015 regulations, said the ‘cap’ wasn’t in the latest draft. In fact, it was, and he himself didn’t have the latest draft, but I did. This occurred during a conference at a London University.
Potentially, because the FIFA regime at the time put the ‘cap’ in, then took it out, then put it back in, reworded it several times between drafts, this was the main cause of such confusion. It was very much like a regulatory ‘Hokey Cokey (pokey)’ and it wasted a lot of time, money and resources but seemingly just confused everyone.
Was the confusion and/or public disagreement intentional …… quite possibly, but it notably resulted in what many perceive as more damage to the industry for many participant groups and stakeholders.
DejaVu in 2020/21 of 2014/15
Over the past 12 months I have had amazing episodes of DejaVu when it comes to the subject of the new FIFA proposals for the introduction of new regulations and notably the mention once again of a ‘cap’ on football agents fees.
Some of the attitudes and approaches of various groups (not just the agents) when it comes to the reported new agent regulations from FIFA (most notably the issues of an agent fee ‘cap’), are reminiscent of ‘2015’ with the bickering, the squabbling, the threats of legal action and not least, the inability to listen, collaborate and find solutions rather than seemingly look solely after their own aims and agendas.
Do I agree with the Agents Fee ‘Cap’?
I have been asked so many times over the years for my opinion on the capping of football agents fees, and to be quite honest in some ways I agree with the idea, and in other ways, I don’t.
Yes : a ‘cap’ on football agent commissions is needed
However, the thought of another ‘advisory cap’, as was the eventual outcome of the 2015 regulations, is laughable and a pointless exercise for all involved.
another ‘advisory’ cap as in 2015,
is laughable and a pointless exercise for ALL involved.
As I have said to several people, maybe the intention of the old FIFA regime at the time (2015), was to cause confusion and a very public ‘debate’ over a 3% cap (added to drafts, removed, reworded) and to put the 3% in the psyche of participants (e.g. clubs and players) to the extent that it would eventually be adopted ……………. quite predictably, it wasn’t.
There is no doubt in my mind that in some (and I stress SOME) cases a cap is needed to curb the excesses of what I perceive to be a small fraction of agents. Such cases have seemingly increased in recent years, as it is reported that some agents are taking an increasingly larger slice of player salaries (directly and indirectly) and even transfer fees: 40,50,60 even 70%.
No : the ‘capping’ of football agent fees will cause more problems and damage
As an agent (registered intermediary) you would be right in thinking that I object to the ‘cap’ being mentioned in reports of FIFAs new draft regulations.
YET this is not because it is a cap, but more so that it is (reportedly) an unreasonable cap that will not only affect the legitimacy and effectiveness of my work (and others), but also the level of service and support that is offered to clients by agents, both good and bad.
As with any business, if their revenue is cut the decision has to be made as to how they balance out the reductions. Do they cut their profits or do they cut their costs, and/or decrease the quality of service and support offered to their customers to accommodate the loss in revenue?
would the ‘capping’ of agents fees,
be detrimental to the more than just the agents?
So, a clear question to be asked is; “by capping agents fees, do you cap the level/quality of service they offer to their clients, that in turn is detrimental to the football industry and its stakeholders?”
What I would add however. is that those who reportedly charge extortionate agents’ fees will continue to charge extortionate fees irrelevant of an unworkable cap or not. They will take commissions by such means as payments ‘under the table’ and undeclared, they will break and bend the regulations and some may well just operate as unlicensed agents (outside of the football regulations).
Is There a Reasonable Solution?
Despite what many might say, I believe there are possibilities for a reasonable solution to this issue. These will undoubtedly won’t please everyone (as many people in football are notoriously difficult characters to please) and undoubtedly some will continue to break rules and regulations or operate unlicensed ……. yet is that anything new?
Is the best solution then, for us not to have the majority of agents, FIFA and other stakeholders operating inside of the boundaries set out in the regulations (cap or no cap) for mutual benefit and in a reasonable, fair, transparent and collaborative environment?
Whilst I appreciate that some agents may see the introduction of such a cap as a ‘slippery slope’, where the likes of FIFA could push in the future to reduce such a cap yet further to effectively ‘strangle’ the football agent’s industry …. I believe this could also be avoided.
Is There a ‘Magic Number‘ for Such a ‘Cap‘?
For me, like so many others, the notion of a reported 3% (6% if acting for multiple parties) is purely unworkable and unsustainable. It will arguably result in good agents leaving the industry (creating a vacuum for more questionable operators), payments going ‘under the table’ (undeclared), more unlicensed agents, degraded services to clients (players & clubs) and even the potential for increased transfer fees and the transfer market becoming even more unstable.
There is no ‘magic number’ as to where a cap can be set, whether it be 3%, 5%, 10%, 20%, 50% or 12.658825% (I jest), however high or low, it will be too high for some (i.e. FIFpro, ECA) and too low for others (agents).
For example, 3% commission representing a 2nd choice goalkeeper in England’s League 2 is very different to –
a 3% commission on a £100m + transfer fee for a player from the Bundesliga to the Premier League.
there might not be a magic number for
setting a ‘cap’ on football agents fees.
Many agents I speak to I would guess never expect anything more than around 10-15% commission on a transaction (cumulative of those clients represented; typically, just the player), and I would say most wouldn’t dream of anything in excess of 20%.
In fact, back in approximately 2014, I presented the idea that the approach should be to negotiate an agreed cap on agents’ commissions with the likes of FIFA. This was on the basis that it would be set for a predetermined period and could not be decreased without the agreement of a representative agents panel.
Needless to say, this suggestion was ‘shot down’ by some agents who I can only assume may have been charging far more than that being suggested, or they just wanted a fight with FIFA and/or just didn’t like to be told (by either FIFA or myself).
Proportionate and Fair
The crux for me (and I would guess many others), is that any such cap on agents’ fees is proportionate to the services delivered and the success in delivery. After all, how many football fans cry out that their teams’ players should receive performance-related pay (notably, when the team isn’t getting results) and in most industries, if someone does a good job there is an acceptance that they get paid for their efforts and their client’s success.
a very difficult task for FIFA to address (fairly),
and a very fine balancing act.
However, measuring the performance of football agents is a difficult thing to do. Not only is each transaction different in terms of value, level, market and participants, but quite often representing different or even multiple parties on the same transaction (more on that in part 2 of this article and from an article back in 2016). Added to that, different agents operate in very different ways and invest different amounts of time and resources into looking after their clients …. so, who (and how) can adequately judge whether a commission is proportionate with so many variables?
Granted, this is a very difficult task for FIFA to address and a very fine balancing act, set it too high they will be criticised, and set it too low they will be criticised.
