Why the Reluctance & Opposition to the Reintroduction by FIFA of the ‘Licensed’ Football Agents Exam?

Putting to one side the positives and negatives of what ‘FIFA 2.0’ are proposing (which from what I have seen are largely positive, especially following the steps taken by the ‘Old FIFA’ in 2015), a key part of the new proposal is the reintroduction of an exam for ‘Licensed’ Football Agents to pass in order to be granted the new license by FIFA.

Information is still sketchy on what form the exam will take, how it will be implemented and how it will be delivered. But, given that there has been no requirement by FIFA (or many National Football associations, such as English FA) for new agents (intermediaries) to sit or pass such an exam since 2015, you would expect this to be a welcome step, and a step in the right direction.

Well, you (and I) would be wrong …. there are objections being voiced from various quarters about the reintroduction of a FIFA Football Agents exam, many of which in my opinion are misguided, unwarranted and in some cases just ludicrous. So why is this the case?

Registered Intermediaries Post 2015

Many would think the first cries of derision at the proposition of an exam being introduced by FIFA would be those Registered Intermediaries who have been ‘authorised’ in the intervening period since April 2015. Those who haven’t been required to sit the exam but now possibly have this thrust upon them to save the businesses and client bases they may well have built.

However, from my own perspective this is not the case as many of this group wanted to take an exam. Some in 2014/15 were even advised not to (by the football authorities) or just couldn’t sit the exam, as no exam existed when they registered.

Some more established agents may well make accusations that the group registered post 2015 aren’t experienced or qualified enough and should take the exam. Yet, in my experience, this is simply not the case. In fact, many of those registered intermediaries that registered post 2015 have taken the initiative to voluntarily educate themselves on football regulations and other topics; to the extent that they are arguably just as qualified and competent as some of those licensed way before 2015 (who also haven’t been required to sit an exam).


Large Agencies and the ‘Old Guard’

Yes, that is correct (and without going too much into the history of the licensing of Football Agents and the exam), many long established footballs agents have never sat any form of agents exam, seen the exam (that did exist) …. let alone passed the exam – but they still feel the right to comment in a negative manner on the exam(s).

Yet in one breath some of this group deride the exam; that is when they aren’t deriding the newer intermediaries and agents as not having the necessary knowledge or experience (which is often not true).

In fact, ‘behind closed doors’ some of these more established agents agree the old agent’s exam is tough (if they have actually seen it), one or two have allegedly even sat it voluntarily (some have allegedly failed). So, again we may ask; what is the foundation for their objections?

larger agencies and established agents
want to maintain control, or avoid losing face?

It could be the fact they fear that if they were to fail the new exam, they would ‘lose face’ or even lose their license (which one some value more is debatable at times). Thus, impacting on their businesses and client-bases which they have built up over the years. However, it is hard to believe that the new ‘FIFA 2.0’ would not allow for some dispensations to this group for being registered and/or licensed for so long. That is if such a highly experienced and knowledgeable group need such dispensations, and should in all reality find such an exam a ‘breeze’ to pass.

In fact, this group and anyone licensed prior to 2014’ish should be grateful FIFA didn’t adequately uphold the old regulations. As under Article 17 of FIFA pre 2015 agent regulations: ‘The licence expires five years after its date of issue’, at which point it was intended for the agents to reapply and resit the exam …. which didn’t happen (to my knowledge at least).

Maintaining Control

There is some suspicion that the ‘Old Guard’ would like to control the regulation of their fellow agents, or have a controlled influence over licensing and subsequently the exam. Whilst there may be a legitimate argument (in their opinion) over the relevance of some questions on the old exam(s), in my experience most (if not all) of the questions that I have seen were relevant, if at times ambiguous. More importantly however, is that the more ambiguous questions meant that successful candidates had more of an understanding of the football regulations, how to interpret them and how to apply them.

The Growth of Big Agencies

Added to the fact that the more established agents may want an element of control (if only for some to ‘feed egos’), there is no denying the fact that since 2015 the larger agencies have arguably seen a growth in the number of licensed intermediaries (agents) they operate within their organisations. This has seemingly allowed for these agencies to have more market influence, greater market coverage, a larger market share and greater control.

Some would say quite cynically that a number of these individuals who are now Registered Intermediaries (since 2015) are those who operated as ‘runners’ and ‘advisors’ (if not unlicensed agents) for the same agencies pre-2015, and either had failed the exam previously or would have had difficulty in passing it.

A Double Edged Sword for Larger Agencies

This has however been seemingly a ‘double edged sword’ for many of the larger agencies. The more effective ‘operators’, who now found themselves as Registered Intermediaries, discovered autonomy and chose to leave their parent organisations/agencies to set up as independents or as their own agency and in many cases taking their clients with them.

As such, does this not raise the question that in having control of, or obstructing the introduction of a new football agent’s exam, it helps the larger agencies and more established agents, in that they can potentially:

  • Operate more unsuitably qualified ‘Agents’ under their ‘umbrella’.
  • Regain their former employees (and their clients) as less influential ‘runners’ (regaining more control).
  • Avoid sitting the exam themselves, as there is no guarantee they will pass, Afterall …………

……. How many of us would be confident in passing our driving test tomorrow, given the bad habits we have developed over time and the things we have got away with for so long?


‘Genies Out of the Bottle’ in 2015

No matter whether you are in favour of a Football Agent’s exam or against it; most will agree that the Intermediary regulations introduced by the ‘old FIFA’ in 2015 were a huge mistake. 2015 was a bad move and for various reasons made matters far worse for many in football (including FIFA, agents, players, clubs).

But there is one group who benefitted from this rash and misguided decision, and that is those who registered in 2015 as ‘Intermediaries’ (agents) with very few checks in place, and many of those may well object to the introduction of a new FIFA Agents Exam (and new regulations).

2015 let the ‘genie out of the bottle’
for many ‘chancers’ to make a ‘quick buck’

Included in this group were those who arguably operated as ‘unlicensed agents’ before 2015 because they chose not to be licensed and thus operated outside of the regulations and in addition to this, there were those who had failed the exam (often repeatedly). Both of these were seemingly in many cases given ‘free-reign’ to become ‘Registered Intermediaries’ often for the payment of a nominal fee to a national association and minimal checks into their own character and past.

Now before many of those registered since 2015 ‘jump down my throat’ I will once again state that there are many who would have sat the exam if they could and have since gone on to prove themselves to be very competent, professional and respected intermediaries and should be applauded and acknowledged for their efforts. Yet even they would agree with me that 2015 let the ‘genie out of the bottle’ for many ‘chancers’ to make a ‘quick buck’, sew disinformation (e.g. to players), destabilise football and arguably misrepresent many clients (young and old). Many of these ‘chancers’ would not want to see an exam introduced as they would have no interest in making the effort to study, let alone actually sit and pass the exam.   


Convenient Overseas Agent Registration

An inability to pass the exam (and/or pass any checks of character/reputation) were also not an obstacle to many even prior to 2015 for some ‘agents’. The inability to register in one country; whether it be down to the exam, character checks or the possibility of sanctions (past and future) and questionable conduct, resulted in some registering in another country/territory as an ‘agent’.

Even despite FIFAs efforts to legislate against such practices some agents and intermediaries have registered in countries where their credibility, character and conduct wasn’t scrutinised as thoroughly as it should have been. In the case of pre 2015 exams, there have been reports that exams may have been sat under more ‘favourable’ conditions in some territories.

exams may have been sat under
more ‘favourable’ conditions in some territories

This results in another group who may have some objections to FIFA introducing a new agent exam for licensing, especially if this is backed up by requirements as to where an exam is taken and ‘FIFA 2.0’ taking a ‘firmer hand’ with how exams are administered and licensing undertaken.


Legal Professionals

You may well think that lawyers and legal professionals would have no hesitation in sitting yet another professional regulatory test that is seemingly far simpler than the assessments and requirements they have to fulfil in their profession. Yet sadly, with some, you would be wrong.

There are some legal professionals (lawyers) who reject the notion of having to sit an exam through FIFA, or undertake any periodical assessment or development. Prior to 2015, there was a category of ‘agent’ that encompassed those with suitable legal experience/qualifications being declared as ‘Registered Lawyers’ (e.g., with the FA), who, based on basic legal criteria were exempt from sitting the football agents’ exam.

why would highly intelligent professionals resist
sitting a comparatively straightforward exam?

So why would such a group of supposedly highly intelligent professionals resist the notion of sitting an additional and comparatively straightforward exam? Is it the notion of superiority and sitting with the ‘great unwashed’ (who aren’t lawyers), is it the fear of failure or something else?

Whilst I have a huge amount of respect for many in the legal profession, and I would expect any half decent lawyer who took the time to educate themselves about the football regulations to pass an agent’s exam without a problem (much like an experienced agent); there does still seem to be objections.

In fact, I used to be of the opinion that this exemption was correct and fair, these people have studied long and hard to become qualified lawyers and they will know these regulations (and the law) inside out, but how wrong I was.

One of my best friends is a lawyer (unconnected with football) and quite often we lament about the football world and how at times it has a total disconnect with the real world and also common and standard legal practices.

Added to this I have witnessed plenty of lawyers (not employment, commercial, litigation experts – who are seemingly amongst the most adept in agent matters) ‘chance their arm’ at being a Football Agent, sometimes even without the knowledge of their firm.

Is it the misguided kudos of being a football agent or the chance of some extra money? Both of which I find hard to believe as (i) the widely held perception and image of a football agent I would argue is detrimental to that of a lawyer, and (ii) most agents can only dream of getting the secure salary of a lawyer?

Those ‘Registered Lawyers’ who took it on themselves to sit the old Agents exam are some of the people I have the most respect for and many of them don’t even act as agents, they did it so that they had a better understanding of the industry and regulations and to better support the interests of their clients (e.g., players, clubs, coaches and agents). So, in sitting a relatively short and straightforward exam for such an educated and professional person where is the problem? They should really pass it ‘at a canter’ and have no objections to the notion of sitting it like everyone else.


Passing the Old Exam

As someone who passed the old FIFA Licensed Football Agents exam, my take on the possibility of a new FIFA Agents exam may surprise some, especially as I may have to re-sit it; given that in 2015 my success (efforts and cost) at passing the exam was effectively made worthless and scrapped by the ‘old FIFA’.

I took great pride in passing the exam (and still do), it was far from easy (when compared to other academic and professional exams I have sat, not as tough as the IAAF Athlete Representatives exam) and this is backed up by a reportedly low pass rate of between 8% and 15% (in England) over the years.

a Football Agent’s exam with a reported
low pass rate of between 8% and 15%

Thus, to hear a few voices who have little or no knowledge of the exam (let alone any appreciation) constantly belittle it and undermine the efforts and achievements of myself (and many others) really does ‘#### me right off’!

Yes, some questions were (as I remember) a bit quirky and ambiguous, but they force you to know all of the regulations and think. Some questions I believe deliberately tried to catch applicants out, and that is quite right for an industry where undoubtedly people do try to catch you out and situations can be complicated and often contrived.

I would be lying if I said I didn’t have some in trepidation over sitting a new FIFA agents’ exam in the future, as failing it would threaten what I have built up over many years, my professional reputation and also my livelihood. Yet I know damn well that this would force me to make sure I was up to date with the regulations (old and new) and ensure I was competent enough to represent my clients and work in their best interests.

Put quite simply for anyone who argues against the introduction of some form of test of professional competency (if not just basic knowledge) whether it be an exam or other form(s) of evaluation in an industry which undoubtedly needs it to develop any form of improvement, positive reputation and professionalism, is simply quite ludicrous without clear, objective and fair justification.










You may also like...