Introducing the ACA10 Concept ‘Football Agent Commissions Audit’ – An Alternative to FIFAs Hard ‘Cap’ on ‘Excessive‘ Football Agent Commissions

Over the past 4 years (almost) there has been an ongoing debate (and process) over the re-introduction by FIFA of the Football Agent license and subsequent regulations (something I have covered in previous articles).

Whilst it would be unfair to say that no progress has been made, I think I am justified in saying progress has been slow and problematic. Not least due to the impasse and failure of various parties to try and find concessions over a few key issues.

One of the key issues that has remained a constant and a key contentious area of debate, argument and fervent objection from the proposed FIFA Football Agent Regulations (FFAR) is that of a ‘cap’ on agent commissions (service fees).

Introducing the ACA10 Concept ‘Football Agent Commissions Audit’ - An Alternative to FIFAs Hard ‘Cap’ on ‘Excessive‘ Football Agent Commissions

Without straying too much into the legalities of the ‘cap’ or the notion of the cap in terms of its fairness and effectiveness (covered in other articles); it is fair to say many have presented to FIFA alternatives to the proposed ‘cap’ to allow for progress to be made with the implementation of the much needed new FIFA Football Agent Regulations (FFAR).

Such proposals for alternatives to negate the impasse and disputes have included limitations on conflicts of interests and tiered/banded capping structures, yet it seems none of these alternatives have been considered by FIFA as viable, and instead FIFA seem transfixed on a hard-fixed cap; whether motivated to do so internally or by influence from external stakeholder factions.


Introduction to ACA10 – (Football) ‘Agent Commission Auditing’ concept

Just one of the alternative proposals submitted to FIFA came from the idea of an industry associate of mine (with much experience of the football industry and compliance as a lawyer, investigator and agent); which we subsequently worked on together to ‘fine-tune’ for submission to FIFA.  We called it ACA10 (Agent Commission Audit 10). Please note, this was just one of many concepts and proposals we could have submitted – yet we adjudged this to be one of the most reasoned and viable concepts at this point (January 2022), due to the various circumstances at the time.

ACA10 takes the form of an ‘auditing’ process for football agent commissions (service fees) as an alternative to the hard ‘cap’ proposed by FIFA under the new draft FFAR; and thus, negates some of the objections to a ‘cap’ and ultimately negates many of the legal challenges to the imposition of a ‘cap’.

As with FIFAs stated aims (including those of the new FFAR) to address issues of ‘excessive fees’ and ‘greater transparency’, ACA10 focusses on providing an added layer of transparency, refocussing greater scrutiny on the seemingly more excessive practices whilst also ‘side-stepping’ the contentious issue of a ‘cap’; that is until a more meaningful way is found for assessing what the threshold will be for deeming a commission ‘excessive’.


‘Excessive’ Agent Service Fees and Practices

The term ‘excessive’ is something that has frustrated me on this topic for several months, and as I have long stated, judging what is ‘excessive’ is a subjective question based on the person and the situation to which they are applying judgement to. At the most basic level, if you take 3 sugars in your tea/coffee, someone else may deem that to be excessive.

So, when FIFA officials and others repeatedly ask me what is ‘excessive’, it is irrelevant; as that is my judgement and may well vary from one ‘actor’ to another and vary based on the nuances of one ‘situation’ compared to another.

This is further exacerbated in the football agent context based on the nuances of the industry itself; on such factors as who the agent is representing (some would argue is even exacerbated under the proposed FFAR), the services they are providing and the market and territory where the representation is taking place.


Complications of Football Agent Activity

Many outside of the football agent industry have a rather uninformed view of how the industry operates (including other football stakeholders and even some in football governance), probably skewed by media sensationalism. As such, there are disparate perspectives and biased views of the industry and its practices, not least identifying which agents are undertaking arguably ‘excessive’ practices and which are not.

It is easy for many to lazily label all agents and their practices ‘excessive’ without understanding their roles, the industry or the relative situation. Subsequently, the ‘excessive’ practices of the few, sees a ‘cap’ applied unfairly to the many, without quantifying the ‘excesses’, let alone deploying a viable solution.

Therefore, one of the key benefits of ACA10 was that of being able to monitor agent commissions and subsequent marketing practices and justify what may be deemed to be ‘excessive’ practices compared to the market as a whole, and IF feasible apply some form of reasoned and fair ‘capping’ mechanism in the future.


‘Never Say Never‘ – With a ‘Cap‘ on Agents Fee

The concept of ACA10 does not rule out the possibility of a ‘capping’ mechanism on football agent commissions in the future, it is a means of monitoring and analysing where excessive practices may be deemed to exist, and quantifying such thresholds against the industry as a whole.

In addition to this, the added transparency that ACA10 brings; not only in terms of monitoring but also wider scrutiny by football stakeholders (e.g. fans) and interested parties (e.g. media) gives foundation to improving the scrutiny of not just agent practices, but also identifying conflicts of interest as well as those that may facilitate such excessive agent practices (e.g. clubs, managers, players, club executives, regulators) whether intentionally or otherwise.


In Summary

The ACA10 is not seen as a ‘silver bullet’ in addressing the excessive practices that exist in a small proportion of the football agent industry, it is one tool in a toolbox that looks to address the wider issues.

It does not rule out the notion of some form of ‘capping’ mechanism for agents’ fees and addressing excesses in the football agency industry …….. but if one was deemed necessary ACA10 would help set the thresholds fairly and legitimately.

Download the ACA10 Concept Document v1.1p (FOOTBALL AGENT COMMISSION AUDIT CONCEPT) from :

https://bit.ly/ACA10-FIFA

OR

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1OsE2TCRU0UBD9U2kRs_YQ6KPEaw52kEK/view?usp=sharing

You may also like...