Has the Subject of Football Agents Become Footballs Convenient ‘Dead-Catting’ Distraction

Over recent years it seems that the phrase ‘Throwing a Dead Cat on the Table’ has become an increasingly used expression, particularly in reference to much of the questionable activity and decisions in political spheres.

Now, heaven forbid I want to get embroiled in debating the seemingly dark, murky, scurrilous world of self-interest and nefarious activity that is politics. No, I want to keep this article light and keep with a far more glowing world and shining light of philanthropy, good will, honesty and integrity that is football and focussing again on football agents (for those who missed the joke there, I was being sarcastic).

Football Agents : a convenient distraction for footballs 'dead-catting' strategy?

Football Agent Problems Stretching Back Many Years

For those who have read my other articles, heard my comments from other sources or indeed met me; you know that I have consistently over many years strived for, encouraged and campaigned for, the improvement of regulating the football agent industry. For which I would honestly say has largely been greeted with, at best, a disingenuous ‘pat on the back’ and more often searing criticism from many based on their own self-interest, and cynicism or an ambivalent ‘shrug of the shoulders’ from many others (including those in football governance).

the regulation of football agents –
why has this ‘boil on the backside’ not been lanced?

So why has this ‘boil on the backside’ of football been allowed to remain if not fester and grow, rather than be treated and or metaphorically lanced? In fact, the issues and problems regarding the regulation of football agents goes back further than my involvement in the industry; with FIFA, UEFA, many national football associations, leagues, even various governments declaring ‘something must be done’ …. yet doing nothing plausible or meaningful.

Now, I readily note the efforts of the new ‘FIFA 2.0’ regime, to reintroduce the Registered Agents License accompanied by new regulations, which are scheduled for some time in 2022. Yet, I think despite being encouraged by the intention of ‘new’ FIFA, I and many others will be excused for collectively taking the success of such regulations with a ‘pinch of salt’, unless they are implemented sensibly and meaningfully enforced (although the signs are largely positive thus far).


Dodgy, Slimy and Treacherous Agents Deserve a Good ‘Kicking‘

It is nothing new for agents to be the ‘go to’ target for criticism and ridicule by media, pundits, clubs and fans alike. When there is bad news in football finance such as a club falling into administration, or a club paying a reportedly extortionate transfer fee for a player along with their huge salary, invariably it is an excuse to report and blame the involvement of lecherous agents and the old adage of them ‘taking money out of the game’.

I agree that quite often the criticism of some agents is well deserved, but more often than not the headlines are skewed and misrepresented, if not sensationalised to feed already common caricatures of what is a very misunderstood industry where agents are clumped together (good, bad, large, small, licensed, unlicensed).

“Dodgy, slimy and treacherous agents,
remain the rogue traders of football”

“There is a caricature of the average football agent as slimy, dodgy and treacherous. I have probably met 30 or 40 over my time as a journalist, and do you know what? The caricature is wrong in only one, crucial respect: it grossly underestimates just how disreputable these parasites really are”

……. not my words, but those of an arguably reputable journalist for The Times in 2015.

Just to be clear ………….

  • the same journalist had ‘met 30 or 40’ (out of hundreds, if not thousands of agents) over his many years as a journalist. Is that a fair sample, or just a convenient caricature for him to conjure up?
  • the same journalist then presented at an agent’s association meeting several weeks later to speak on the subject, whilst also promoting his new book. Well at least it quadrupled the number of agents he had ‘met’, in just one day.
  • do I draw the same conclusion about all journalists from those that I have met …? No, but then again, I am not trying to sell papers or even my latest book.

The question has to be asked in each and every case: ‘is the agent solely to blame’, or should others also have to take responsibility for the agent’s activity’, such as in governing questionable football agent activity or even facilitating it?

Now, I understand that on many occasions the media ‘kicking’ an agent (or ‘agents’, as a collective) is convenient, but are the media being used in someone else’s ‘dead cat’ strategy? Does this deflect attention and criticism away from those who may also be to blame, or even primarily to blame? Which is in many cases, just because the media wants to keep strategists sweet for future headlines and interviews (e.g., club, association).


So Why Are Football Agents Often Footballs ‘Dead Cat’?

The term of ‘throwing a dead cat on the table’ (‘dead-catting’) is a relatively new (and rather distasteful) phrase to me, and more notably used in an apparent mist of confusion and misinformation that has presented itself to us all in recent ‘covid times’.

The practice of ‘presenting a dramatic, shocking, or sensationalist topic to divert attention and discourse away from a more damaging topic’ is nothing new. It is something I recognise from politics, business, football headlines and life in general; the phrase in itself ‘dead-catting’ was relatively new.

many years of ‘wanting to do something’
on the topic of football agent regulations

nothing more than, PR exercises, ‘spin’ and empty promises

I can see now, how it may be a perfectly feasible distraction tactic for those in football (and connected to football) to use the topic of football ‘agents’ as a plausible target for ‘dead-catting’; whether it be clubs, national associations, leagues, media, FIFA or even politicians.

Having worked for, encouraged and campaigned (often vehemently) for better football governance; I have heard all the statements about reform, positive change, better regulations, ‘wanting to do something’ on the topic of football agent regulations and governance. Most of which transpire to be nothing more than ‘mealy mouthed’ statements, PR exercises, ‘spin’ and empty promises (e.g. Premier Leagues announcement in 2018 to address Football Agent regulation issues, for which some 3 years later we are still waiting). But are these examples of a ‘dead-catting’ strategy by some in football and the topic of football agents is an easy target – given the widespread misunderstanding of the industry (of which I spoke earlier) and thus resentment by many football stakeholders (including fans and supporters)?


The Annual ‘Dead-Cat’ – Agent Declarations and Fees

The most blatant and convenient ‘dead-catting’ exercise in terms of football agents occurs annually around March/April time (in England), when the FA, Premier League and EFL release the latest fees paid to agents by clubs AND PLAYERS. I stress the mention of players there, as just one of the convenient misinterpretations here is that the fees in these reports are paid solely by clubs, which is not the case.

a blatant and convenient annual ‘dead-catting’ exercise,
in terms of football agents?

Annually, the outcry over how much has been paid to agents never surprises me, and quite often it doesn’t just last a day, it lasts weeks.

So, is this topic a convenient ‘dead-cat’, should there be something else for clubs, the leagues or even national associations to distract unwanted attention from? ……. I am not saying it is, just asking the question.


‘Dead-Cat Transfer’

In writing this article I may well look to ‘copyright’ the phrase ‘dead-cat transfer’ (apologies if someone has used it before), but with all the attention given to football transfers and most notably ‘transfer deadline day’ …. just how many transfers or transfer stories are employing a ‘dead cat’ strategy?

It could just be a long-standing practice from agents or clubs to make a transfer happen, deflect away from their true intentions, generate interest in a player or raise the transfer fee (and/or salary) …… something I am not going to deny happens (albeit historically in breach of football agent regulations).

a growing trend to inflate the role of agents when reporting of transfers, most notably when a transfer has ‘broken down’.

Yet I have noticed one thing in recent transfer windows and that is the trend to make agents and agents fees more prominent in the reporting of transfers, most notably when a transfer has ‘broken down’.

Just how convenient is it for a club that had no intention of signing a player, to blame agents (and their fees) as the reason for the signing of a ‘star player’ to falter? That way to their fans, the club are the innocent party and the wrath of the fans (via the media) is aimed on those “Dodgy, slimy and treacherous agents remain the rogue traders of football” yet again.

No mention of the club’s past/present dealings with the same agent, them leaving the transfer to the last minute, the players demands or even all parties involved collectively building in contingency for agent’s fees that would have more than likely been known early on in the negotiation process.

Was it a transfer and contract ‘on the table’ or was it a ‘dead cat (transfer) on the table’?


A Confession – More Chance than Judgement

I must confess this theory of a widespread ‘dead cat’ strategy in football came about rather by chance, than any real in-depth analysis or judgement on my part.

In fact, I have the UK Government to thank, as they seemingly in recent times have used football itself as a ‘dead cat’ to distract from other matters. Whether it be the ESL (European Super League), a heralded fan led football governance review, safe standing in grounds, independent football regulator or in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic allowing fans back into matches or even reports of UK government liaising with UEFA to offer to host the whole of Euro 2020.

So, the next time football agents or agent regulations make the headlines I will hope you will start to think …… is this someone conveniently ‘throwing a dead cat on the table’ to distract away from other matters they would prefer you (and others interested in football) not to pay attention to, whether it be a club, league, national association or some other football related party (or even government) who is ‘dead-catting’.










You may also like...