FIFA’s New Football Agent Regulations (FFAR) have drawn a lot of criticism – Is it time to focus on the Positives rather than just the negatives?
There has been enough negative commentary and observations written in regards to the new FIFA Football Agent Regulations (FFAR) following their public release last week – in fact, I may be accused of being unfair and overly critical by some (something which I vehemently dispute).
Whilst I could reiterate much of what has been said/written already (if not add to it), I think it only right that we highlight the good points from these new regulations; not least as I had already written a white paper back in March 2022 (in the article: ‘40,000+ Words on the Viability of Proposals & Proposed Resolutions for Football Agent Regulations …..why?’). This was based on what at the time, was supposedly the final draft of the regulations (from which, arguably not a huge amount has changed).
As I have said in the numerous calls, emails and other queries I have fielded in the last week from agents, media, football stakeholders and other interested parties; in regards to the new FFAR I will say that I think the vast majority of what FIFA have put in the FFAR is positive, despite it being let down by a few large and ominous problems yet to be resolved, either through negotiation, mediation, arbitration (e.g., PROFAA at CAS) or unfortunately litigation.
In fact, on some aspects I think FIFA could have gone further to address other problems in the agency world which they have overlooked; but for now, let’s focus on the positives.
**Again I will get my own disclaimer in early, I am neither a lawyer nor a legal professional, and as such refer to trusted professionals for legal opinion and expertise.**
The Reintroduction of the FIFA (Football) Agents License
The reintroduction of the agent’s license (albeit slightly different to pre-2015), is one that I think many people have welcomed, whether this be a case of genuine approval or motivated by self-interest (e.g., some ‘legacy’ agents).
The question remains however, as to the true value of the license to those who hold it and those who will be subject to licensed agent activity. FIFA and the Member (National) Football Associations (MAs) hold the key to this, as ultimately the license has value based on its credibility that is underpinned by effective and fair regulation and sanctions.
Reintroduction of the FIFA Licensed Agents Exam
For many the reintroduction of the agent’s exam is again to be welcomed and despite some questioning its relevance or the subject matter upon which it is based, the exam is a step up from what went before (2015-2023), with no exam and thus no measure of basic knowledge of regulations. Whilst the information as to the exam format presented by FIFA thus far seems largely to be a fair and relatively robust testing system to assess minimum knowledge of the regulations (e.g., random questions generated), there are some question marks over consistency between MA’s and the testing environment (e.g., possible manipulation, if not ‘cheating’ the exam). However, I think we must remain hopeful that FIFA will look to address any weaknesses in the exam and the exam conditions that are seemingly very open to manipulation.
Football Agent CPD (Continuing Professional Development)
On a personal note, the introduction of a comprehensive programme of CPD, and the requirement for licensed agents to acquire a specified number of CPD points in an annual period to remain licensed, is one of the elements I congratulate FIFA for the most.
Many agents (pre-2015) and intermediaries (post 2015) recognise the need to keep fully aware and up to date with the regulations for both their own benefit and the benefit of their clients (i.e., rightly seen as a necessity rather than a chore). It would be safe to say that previously, agents have had to search and scramble around for various regulatory documents from a wide variety of sources both from FIFA and the MA’s, and even then ‘version check’ the resource to establish if they were the latest applicable regulation.
So, in FIFA making available what we are led to believe will be a comprehensive programme of CPD for agents (all included as part of the licensing fee), and the ongoing requirement for licensed agents to attain a certain number of CPD points annually as part of their licensing process – should be celebrated as valuable addition, not just for agents but also their clients and the wider group of football stakeholders.
Conflicts of Interest – (Dual Representation/Duality & Triality)
This is a topic that when it comes to football agents draws me criticism and ridicule, as well as consensus and sometimes time praise. ‘Conflicts of Interest’ in football are subject to a variety of issues whether they be cultural, national legislation, financial or just ethics and morals.
From a personal and professional standpoint, I don’t agree with such aspects as duality (dual representation) and triality in regards to football agents, whereas some do. Yes, I appreciate the fact that in representing a player, if that player signs for the club it is also of benefit to the club, BUT an ‘agent’ (both in legal and football terms) duty of care in any negotiation should be solely towards one client (as in the case of a lawyer not being permitted to represent both plaintiff and respondent in a legal case).
With that said whilst I welcome FIFA taking some steps to address ‘conflicts of interest’, this in itself may cause other problems as a result of other aspects of the FFAR, as well as the contradiction and possible confusion from ‘permitted duality’ in the FFAR.
Agent Licensing for the Representation of Football Coaches and Managers
On the subject of potential ‘conflicts of interest’, until recently (grazie/thankyou to Paolo Lombardi for the valuable knowledge), I was unaware that there was the legal view that subject to jurisprudence; licensed agents (2008-2015) were NOT permitted to represent coaches/managers under FIFA regulations due to the possibility for a clear ‘Conflict of Interest’.
This may come as a surprise to many agents, coaches/managers and football stakeholders, as it is widely acknowledged that many coaches/managers are (or have been) represented by agents/intermediaries who also represent players and clubs. Therefore, although the new FFAR don’t outlaw the representation of coaches/managers by licensed agents, making it explicit in the FFAR does take steps to seemingly monitor and regulate the practice. Subsequently, this should help with transparency and addresses potential ‘conflicts of interest’ for the benefit of a broader group of football stakeholders.
Representation of Minors
There is no doubt that FIFA have spoken strongly about their intent to protect minors (and rightly so). Therefore, the prerequisite in the FFAR for agents to undertake a specific CPD module on the topic of representing minors before they can represent minors is a welcome step, if only to add at the very least a basic layer of consistency for licensed football agents globally. Whilst some MAs have added additional layers of restrictions nationally in granting permission for agents/intermediaries to represent minors, some have not, thus putting some minors at risk, and an imbalance in the regulations.
Independent Legal Advice
In my experience it is a regular occurrence that many players sign representation agreements with agents/intermediaries without reading or understanding the agent representation agreement (contract), which is to all intent and purposes understandable, as they are not lawyers. The worrying matter is the number of players who sign such agreements ‘blindly’ and do not seek independent legal advice.
Therefore, by FIFA implementing the conditions (Art 12 p.4) for (i) the agent to advise the player-client (in writing) that they should seek such advice, and subsequently for (ii) the player-client to confirm that they have sought such advice OR decided not to, should provide some form of ‘safety net’ for both player and licensed agent, and avoid future disputes.
Whilst this element may still be open to some manipulation (with ‘preferred’ lawyers, and lawyers with a conflict of interest) it is difficult to see what more FIFA could do to ensure players show due diligence when signing with an agent.
From my own viewpoint (and as I have mentioned in past articles), I believe there is an important role if not vital duty here for not just FIFA but also the likes of FIFpro and the national player associations such as the PFA to play. Such as providing a service to their members and non-member players in reviewing such representation agreements. However, this in itself is questionable as some player associations also operate as agents/agencies (whether directly or indirectly) and this is a clear conflict of interest, yet even the provision of a list detailing independent and specialist lawyers (given the nuances of football) to offer such advice to players (and also agents) would be a step in the right direction.
Agents Chamber and Agents Working Group
With the release of the new FFAR, FIFA have also reaffirmed their intention to implement a ‘Agents Chamber’ (to hear disputes relating to agents) and also an ‘Agent Working Group’ (as a consultative group on agent matters). However, at the time of writing (Jan’23), information regarding these entities is very limited and although in the FFAR, these entities are not yet established or operational.
Again, the cited intention of FIFA with both of these entities should seemingly be encouraged, and be a reason for improvement not only for agents but also other football stakeholders affected by agent related activity.
Also, I believe agents should be receptive, if not even welcome this, as it is the first sign of FIFA openly recognising agents as a ‘stakeholder’ rather than just a ‘participant’, which is unfortunately still a view held by many in football including some National Associations (MA’s).
In Conclusion
So, as I stated at the start of this article; I believe the new FIFA Football Agent Regulations (FFAR) are on the whole encouraging. I could draw question marks as to their implementation and some of the more intricate details, but hopefully more details will be provided very soon.
However, whilst I have endeavoured to put a positive tone on the new FFAR, I cannot negate the fact that I still believe them to be severely undermined on some key issues and have to ask the question: are the new FIFA Football Agent Regulations a case of good intentions, but poor execution?
Hopefully these key issues will be addressed and resolved satisfactorily in the not-too-distant future – with meaningful and constructive discussion, for the sake of an industry (and sport) that drastically needs regulatory improvement, not disputes and delays.
.
