Is There Any Light At The End Of The Tunnel For Reform In English Football? (pt 5)
Fiscal Responsibility, Salary Caps, Fair Distribution
Nice Ideas But, Are They All Realistic for Football Reform?
It is difficult to recollect the many discussions, over many years, with many people as to the problems in English Football and possible solutions (many of which have understandably been related to football agents). Yet during this time I have been privileged enough to exchange ideas with, and learn from, many others on the subject, not least from the viewpoints of those with a variety roles and stakeholder positions in football.
A lot of the ideas and things I originally believed to be a positive step to address the problems and issues in areas relating to football governance (including my own) have changed and indeed some I now reflect back on as being naïve and/or now unworkable.
With the rate at which football has evolved in recent decades, and how it has ‘evolved’ (or degenerated, depending on your viewpoint), it is understandable that many ideas and approaches spoken about historically in relation to football governance are now outdated or unworkable.
The other thing to consider in the football ‘community’ is that whilst there is an abundance of selfishness and ‘blinkers’ (and not being able to see a ‘bigger picture’), there is also a clear lack of empathy for others, in a world where there are so many stakeholders (beyond players, associations and clubs) and those who are only focussed on self-interest.
Many Well-Intentioned Ideas, But Are they Workable?
In recent times I have heard so many ideas that purportedly will address the issues in English Football Governance, seeing threats from the likes of a breakaway (ESL) European Super League and more clubs suffering the unfortunate (and I would say avoidable) fate of the likes of Bury and Macclesfield.
Yet the resounding conclusion for me is that there is no ‘silver bullet’ – we need several rounds/bullets to nullify the threats, and a very focussed aim. Whilst most of the arguments for and against some ideas for football governance reform are well-meaning, there is also a large plethora of ideas that haven’t been thoroughly thought through and / or are somewhat are naïve. Yet, more worryingly there are also those coated in a fair amount of sheer bloody mindedness, selfishness and self-interest (most notably from clubs, leagues and related entities).
player salary caps, luxury taxes, 50+1 models & club tax breaks
……. nice ideas : but are they fair, sensible and realistic?
Sadly, a lot of the well-intentioned proposals are idealist views, or just too late to address the issues that are now very difficult to reverse. This largely built on a foundation of academic studies and what has gone before, rather than focussing on the current problems as well as the future and imminent threats.
Some of those ideas and proposals may well work in another sector, but for one reason or another are unlikely to work in the business world of modern football. From player salary caps to luxury taxes, 50+1 models to government backed ground purchases, club fines to tax breaks ……. they are nice ideas (for some), but are they fair, sensible and realistic.
Financial Responsibility (FFP, Profit and Sustainability etc)
There is no doubting that at the heart of many of the woes, problems and threats to English football is ‘FINANCE’. Whether it be irrational overspending in the Championship to get to the Premier League (or National League to the EFL), the suggested greed of projects such as the ESL (European Super League) and ‘Project Big Picture’, or the sheer lack of funds, bad ownership, opportunists and poor fiscal responsibility that see clubs like Bury ‘go out of business’.
Despite the warning signs going back many years, with multiple clubs going into administration and skirting perilously close to liquidation, do clubs and owners learn their lessons?
fining a club already in financial trouble,
what does it achieve?
In fact, do the football authorities and leagues (or even UK government and DCMS), do anything about it in a timely and effective manner, or indeed learn their own lessons?
Yes, some may say we already have measures in place such as FFP (Financial Fair Play), SCMP (Salary Cost Management Protocols) and P&S (Profit and Sustainability), but are they effective and consistent, or just confusing and open to manipulation through such means as ‘creative accounting’ and skilful ‘silver-tongued’ lawyers?
For example:
- In imposing a fine (or similar sanction) on a club already in trouble, what does it achieve?
- In imposing a transfer embargo, how does that help a club actually reduce their wage bill if they cannot replace a player they choose to sell?
Should we not be looking towards ‘prevention rather than cure‘?
Again, I will hold my hand up here and say that although I know a little bit about finance in football, the ‘nuts and bolts’ of the subject ‘bring me out in a cold sweat’ and I turn to some of the accounting and finance whizzes I have the pleasure of knowing who are far more qualified to comment on the topic. Whether it be suggestions of:
- Controlling clubs ‘Debt to Asset Ratios’ (and Gearing) for clubs’ in relation to their borrowing and spending,
- Capping the amount spent on salaries relative to revenues, or even a hard cap on salaries (unjust and unfair in my opinion)
- Limit the loans a club can take out in relation to their revenues
- Periodical independent audits in a specified form for clubs (with specified terminology)
- Requirements for clubs to file full accounts (not small business waivers) and file them on time
no need for clubs to get into financial trouble.
football club licensing,
would mean prevention rather than cure
As I touched upon in my previous article on the concept of a football (club) Licensing System (similar to that of the KNVB in the Netherlands), there is no need for clubs to unnecessarily get into trouble, without concerns being raised independently and action being taken before it is severe let alone too late.
The ‘financial stability’ element of any such ‘licensing system’ would require clubs to be monitored regularly and assessed on not just finance, but other elements such as organisational structure, sporting structure, fan engagement and ownership. If they fail to meet the required grading, necessary steps can be taken by the football authorities to stop matters getting worse and look to rectify the problems WITH the club, thus focussing on prevention rather than cure.
Fairer Distribution of Money and Spending Caps
Much of the argument between clubs and leagues comes down to the matter of money distribution and spending, and whilst I can appreciate this is a key contributing factor in regards to the financial difficulties in some areas of football, I don’t believe it is as simple as ‘taking from the rich to give to the poor’ or telling the wealthier entities that they cannot spend.
Over the last 20 years the football authorities (most notably UEFA and various competitions) have brought in measures referred to collectively as FFP (Financial Fair Play), to allegedly make competition fairer and to ‘level the playing field’.
However, as quickly as FFP guidelines are implemented many clubs find ways to circumvent the rules, and in essence if a club owner or investor wants to lavish (arguably waste) their own money on a club, shouldn’t they be allowed to do so, so long as club assets aren’t used as security (e.g., leveraged buyout) or put at risk.
Football doesn’t need Robin Hood,
‘taking from the rich(er) to give to the poor(er)’
Football (like so many other aspects in the British psyche) invariably has a tendency to support the ‘underdog’; whether it be Wimbledon’s ‘crazy gang’ beating Liverpool (‘culture club’) in the FA Cup Final, or Burnley, arguably ‘punching above their weight’ in the Premier League for many years past, probably down to their shrewd management both and off the pitch and such things as their purported ‘cap and collar’ approach on player wages.
So, in essence shouldn’t a club who gets 20,000 fans a week be allowed to responsibly spend more of that revenue than their rivals who get 5,000 fans a week? Shouldn’t a billionaire be allowed to plough his own money (unguaranteed) into a club, if he has the means to do so?
After all each match is 11 vs 11, and it is up to the club to develop the best 11 to challenge the opposition without screaming ‘it’s not fair’ like a stroppy toddler not getting their own way. Do something about it, work harder, identify talent or move over.
The phrase ‘Moneyball’ is often an over-used term in football now (and often misused), quite frankly since its origins in baseball it has become distorted, if not misunderstood to fit with someone’s narrative. However, the film (and the original story) in essence epitomises how a new idea, approach and just ‘getting on with it’ can see an underdog upset the sporting odds.
Clubs Should .. Look Down with Empathy, Not Just Up with Envy
Yes, there should be fairer distribution of finances between the leagues in English football, but clubs and their representatives (no matter what level in the pyramid) need to learn to look down with empathy, as well as look up with envy.
I don’t believe for one minute that the Premier League giving more money to clubs lower down the ‘pyramid’ will solve the problems (unless in a situation like the impact of covid).
give an irresponsible club/owner more money,
they will find a way to waste it
If you give an irresponsible club more money, they will find a way to spend it and then ask for more (like a kid in an amusement arcade).
Likewise with the suggestion of a ‘luxury tax’ on transfer fees over a certain amount, if that is distributed to other clubs it will inevitably push up prices, push up salaries and inevitably end up probably being spent on transfers.
The problem with the distribution of revenues in English football is not that of the distribution between clubs, but the chasms that are opening up between leagues. This is what results in irresponsible overspending to get promoted, and panic spending to avoid relegation ……. both of which put the future of clubs in jeopardy.
Parachute Payments & Relegation Clauses
As already touched upon, one of the main problems when we hear the cry of ‘it’s not fair’ from clubs is the disparity that has arisen between the leagues (not necessarily in them).
And whilst it is arguably 11 vs 11 over 90 minutes in a league match of seemingly equal opposition (not necessarily resource or finance wise), there is no doubting the disparity that has arisen between the leagues in England.
Whilst many people (myself included) would argue that the idea and intention of ‘parachute payments’ to a club following relegation was good, there is no getting around the fact that the topic is like ‘opening pandoras box’.
Introducing ‘Parachute payments’ may have been well-intentioned,
but has been like opening ‘Pandoras Box’
It is a topic on which I am quite torn. In one way I would like to see ‘parachute payments’ abolished as they are arguably anti-competitive, encourage clubs to overstretch themselves for a longer period, and ‘reward’ failure.
Yet another part of me says that they are somewhat necessary to stop clubs going into ‘freefall’ (financially) following relegation, and if they weren’t in place, we may well end up with a ‘double jeopardy’ situation whereby a club isn’t only relegated but also suffers in the longer term from a financial shortfall which may in turn result in ‘back-to-back’ relegations. Meanwhile the league above maintains the status-quo with its normal club collective and the gap between the divisions/leagues widens yet further.
Although we can’t ‘turn back the clock’ on parachute payments, football needs to find a more effective way to BOTH maintain competitive balance and ensure a club’s financial stability.
The disparity between leagues in terms of revenue is now astounding, and relegation has been proved to result in clubs suffering because of it, resulting in job losses and closure of facilities.
It could be argued that metaphorically those clubs who find themselves in trouble “got to the sweetshop, spent all their money, ate all the sweets and have now got home with tummy-ache” …. so, they have no one but themselves to blame.
However, one anomaly remains for clubs that rely on parachute payments following relegation …. they still retain playing staff on high value contracts, even when other lower salaried non-playing staff (not responsible for relegation) are made redundant and sacrificed.
So, what is the solution to relegated clubs having to still pay high salaries to players (arguably for failure)? Well for me there are many possible ways to address this, each with their own variables.
Relegation Clauses (with Promotion Clauses)
Although this was a ‘no brainer’ for me as an agent, you often find many players and agents who object steadfastly against the notion of relegation clauses in a contract whereby the players salary decreases should the club be relegated. However, a more openminded view would be it gives you the opportunity for better promotion clauses, which when combined with general uplifts (in salary over time) and ‘loyalty bonuses’ in a contract, this could outweigh the potential risk versus reward.
‘Relegation’ clauses ‘cut both ways’ –
Rewarding success &
sharing the responsibility for failure.
There is an argument that such measures as standard clauses for all players would contravene employment law. However, I do believe there is a possibility that such measures could be implemented within footballs ‘standard’ player contracts (with the consent of leagues, clubs and PFA) if done fairly (i.e., a percentage deduction/increase correlating to the guaranteed league and tv revenue difference due to the club between leagues in the year the contract was signed).
After all, if clubs can determine player bonuses, team bonuses, promotion bonuses and contract extensions (and options) in contracts – surely such elements can ‘cut both ways’ fairly and legally?
League Retention ‘Bonuses’
‘Bonuses’ are a potential ‘minefield’ for clubs, players, managers, agents and the football authorities as they can be so varied, complex and subsequently manipulated to suit one or more parties.
However, in balancing out the risk and reward of ‘relegation’ clauses, they are a feasible measure (albeit already included in some player contracts, in one form or another), in that if a club maintains its league status the player receives a ‘non-guaranteed’ sum for the club maintaining its league status.
League Retention ‘Bonuses‘ – a reward for mediocrity,
or a means of achieving the basic target?
Whilst with my former ‘coaches/managers hat on’ I would say it could be argued as a reward for mediocrity, it is not a reward or bonus if done right and in balance with any guaranteed salary and other bonuses. In real world employment terms, it arguably equates to an employee basic salary, OTE (on target earnings) and then bonuses on top.
Yet I do accept that such bonuses may be open to manipulation, and for clubs (and agents) to circumvent any relegation clauses, but then again so could annual uplifts in player salary.
Release Clauses
To balance out the argument against ‘relegation clauses’ from the perspective of the player (and their agent), there could also be a standardisation for release clauses in player contracts.
A player could on relegation have in their contract that:
- their contract is terminated by the club, on pre-defined terms
- the player is made available for transfer for a predetermined transfer fee (i.e., release fee)
or - accept a salary deduction (‘relegation clause’)
Yet the suggestion of ‘Release Clauses’ in player contracts on the event of relegation in itself may cause additional confusion. The other argument against release clauses is that they can be quite destructive if manipulated, such as an unhappy player hoping for a club’s demise as they want a transfer, and thus not performing to the best of their abilities.
Player ‘Release Clauses‘ are a double-edged sword
for both player and club
From the players perspective, release clauses could be seen as a ‘double-edged sword‘ – if they have played well in the previous season, they could move back to a higher level to play and/or secure a new and more lucrative contract. However, a bad season or one hampered by injury and their club being relegated could result in uncertainty for them should they not have the option to accept a salary deduction.
From a club perspective (not looking at it from an accounts, amortisation etc perspective … to make the ‘books look good’–not my area as I have said before) release clauses could be problematic.
For example, a player signed for a large transfer fee makes releasing the player from the contract on relegation a considerable financial/asset loss, but then again if the player hasn’t performed, they may be better cutting their losses.
Likewise, for a player who has performed, having to sell them for a predetermined fee that undervalues the player a season later, is again a loss. However, in both cases, whilst arguably weakening the club’s squad for promotion back to the previous level – they have reduced the wage costs long term, potentially received a transfer fee and are more on par with their rivals in the lower division.
‘One in, One Out’ – Squad Limiting
The approach of limiting the squad is similar to that of a ‘soft transfer embargo’, in that a relegated club can sign new players, but on the basis that one from the previous season is sold/released first, and the contract (salary etc) of the new player does not exceed that of the former player.
The aim is to steadily reduce the costs of the relegated squad and to bring it more on a par with the lower division rivals whilst also reducing club costs and restricting the club from increasing squad spending with the prediction of reduced revenue.
Yet, again without other stipulations such a ‘relegation clauses’ and ‘release clauses’ this may again be a fruitless exercise, with relegated clubs retaining squads on high salaries, and thus gambling on the basis of immediately getting promoted back to the higher division from which they had been relegated.
Securing Long Term Player Salaries
There is nothing forcing a club to offer a 3,4 or 5 year contract to a player. In fact, in the lower divisions it was until recently, quite rare for any player to get more than a 1 or 2 year contract given how lower league clubs would have to be quite frugal in their wage controls. From my own observations it seems that too many clubs (and their owners) are quite ‘blinkered’ in wanting to ‘have their cake and eat it’.
By this I mean that they want freedom to sign players how they want, spend what they want but at the same time want ‘fairer’ distribution of funds (i.e., want more money). They aren’t prepared to sanction financial safeguards/regulations and aren’t prepared to put their money/security ‘up front’ against long term commitments.
too many clubs & owners are ‘blinkered’,
they want to ‘have their cake and eat it‘.
One of these long-term commitments is player contracts and salaries, whether it be 2, 3, 4 or 5 years; they are happy to commit to the player contract. Yet if they sell the club, or the club has financial difficulties, someone else is left having to ‘pick up the tab’ and potentially move the club closer to a ‘financial trapdoor’.
As I stated earlier, I have no issues with any owner/club spending their own money on their club, how they want to (foolish or frugal), so long as it is within the rules (i.e., regarding match fixing, bribes etc), but the matter we have to address is when the risk is in the club’s name and existence.
As such, one suggestion would be that any player contract longer than 2 years and the guaranteed payments related to it, are held in an ‘ESCROW-esque’ facility for the player, and the salary is released to them over the term of the contract. Should the player be sold during that period the money is released back to the club/owner.
Therefore, if the chairman feels the urge to sign a player, or ‘crumbles’ to the latest ‘whim’ of their manager in signing the ‘next starlet’ on a long-term contract (oh yes it happens, far too often), then hopefully it will encourage more due diligence and it is their risk and not gambling with the clubs’ assets (if not future).
Football clubs have plenty of ways to not overspend even when faced with the prospect of promotion or relegation.
They have the choice of a plethora of professional, legal, financial and governance experts to call upon and structure such things as player contracts fairly and sensibly.
The biggest tools available to clubs and their decision makers ……. the ability to say NO!
>>>> Part Six (6), the final part of this article, looks at : “The Problem of English Football’s ‘Fractured’ and Badly ‘Listing’ Pyramid.”
On the topic of ‘Is There Any Light At The End Of The Tunnel For Reform In English Football?‘ – looks at ‘Player Salary Caps, 50+1 Ownership and Protecting Football’s ‘Crown Jewels‘ and asks whether they are just nice ideas, but are they all realistic for effective reform in English Football?
On the topic of ‘Is There Any Light At The End Of The Tunnel For Reform In English Football?‘ – looks at The Problem of English Football’s ‘Fractured’ and Badly ‘Listing’ Pyramid.
